Sunday, February 03, 2008

KBR in the kickback wars again

A former KBR contractor pleaded guilty last week to allegations that he conspired to receive bribes while working in Afghanistan. The contractor Wallace A. Ward was among KBR employees who conspired to receive bribes from drivers hired by the British Red Star Enterprises Limited. The drivers were supposed to deliver jet fuel to the airfield but were instead selling it. The drivers then bribed the KBR employees to prove documents falsely showing that the truckloads of fuel had been delivered to the airfield. Ward now faces a five year sentence while KBR issued a statement saying the company doesn't condone or tolerate unethical behaviour. The scandal is the latest to dog the former Halliburton offshoot which has been mired in controversy over its cosy long-term contractual arrangements with the US military.

KBR (formerly Kellogg Brown Root) rocketed to world attention thanks to its massive $2 billion plus contract to rebuild Iraq’s oil infrastructure. KBR’s massive army logistical support contract known as LOGCAP makes it virtually the newest branch of the US military. It is almost impossible to pick apart the boundary between the two and it is likely that no other company will again be able to compete with KBR for military logistic support given the vastness of the way it become intricately connected with the army, navy and air force.

It was founded in 1919 as a Texas road building company called Brown and Root. Its founding brothers Herman and George Root learned early in life how to influence public officials in order to get lucrative county contracts. They grew steadily in influence culminating in a long relationship with Lyndon Johnson that proved richly rewarded for both the Browns and Johnson. KBR moved from building roads to ships and then began supporting the war effort in World War II. They made big profits in Vietnam but it took its Iraqi involvement to put KBR in the public spotlight for controversy. Taken over by the oil company Halliburton in 1962, its political influence continued when Dick Cheney was appointed CEO in 1995. Cheney had no business experience – he was brought in purely for his influence in Washington.

In 1917 Herman Brown started his business in Texas with a couple of mules moving dirt and grading and paving roads. The demand for road was fuelled by the emergence of cheap cars. Determined to expand, he tapped his brother-in-law Dan Root for a loan. After paying off his creditors, Brown thanked his benefactor by renaming his company Brown & Root. Brown was joined in the business by his younger brother George who was a gifted salesman. Together the brothers lobbied the Texas Highway Department and used payoffs and kickbacks to get themselves a slice of the action.

Brown & Root became masters of a type of contract they were to perfect in Iraq. They would submit a low-bid contract and then having won, ratchet up the costs over time. The brothers moved the business to Houston where they survived the 1929 stock market crash by liquidating their promissory notes. The Depression brought a halt to road building and so Brown & Root had to expand to other unskilled labour tasks to survive. They did everything from repurposing war surplus equipment to hauling garbage for the city of Houston.

The company’s big break was the contract it won for the Marshall Ford Dam. Although the company had no dam building expertise and the dam itself was improperly sold as a flood relief exercise, Brown & Root won the contract by wooing the young local congressman Lyndon Baines Johnson who had the ear of President Franklin Roosevelt. The brothers used non-union labour on an illegal appropriation but relied on its lawyers and influence in Washington to push it through. The eventually dam contract of $17 million was the making of Brown & Root. In return Brown & Root funded Johnson’s initially unsuccessful Senate run and again his ultimate Senate success after World War II. A political and business alliance was formed.

Brown & Root won their first military contract as America headed towards war again. In 1940 they built a Naval Air Station in Corpus Christi, Texas on a “cost-plus” contract which guaranteed profits based on a pre-negotiated percentage. But while Brown & Root’s profits were high, they also gained a reputation for delivery, regardless of whether they were building a dam or a naval base. The end of the war saw a mad scramble firesale of surplus government assets and a consortium led by Brown & Root outbid the oil companies to buy massive pipelines known as Big and Little Inch that ran from the Texas oilfields to the East coast. Brown and Root diversified into natural gas and held a monopoly on supply to the east.

Brown and Root became instrumental in leading a group of Houston businessmen and politicians known as Suite 8F named for the room in the Lamar Hotel where the claque met. For more than twenty years nothing could be done in Houston without the support of this shadowy group. As well as the Brown brothers, the group contained Texan millionaire Jesse H Jones, real estate magnate Gus Wortham, banker James Elkins and iron manufacturer James Abercrombie. Lyndon Johnson was a regular visitor. This was an oil industry lobby group which became a genuine force in Washington. George Brown was appointed to the Space Council and he played a major role in convincing NASA to build its Manned Spacecraft Centre in Houston. Not surprisingly Brown & Root won the contract to build the centre.

Suite 8F suffered a rare defeat when it failed to put Lyndon Johnson into the White House in the 1960 Democratic race. He eventually agreed to become Kennedy’s running mate and became Vice President. Herman Brown died two years later aged 72 and Johnson eulogised that him as a “builder of his community, his country and his world”. Before his death, Herman had started talks with Halliburton to take over the company. The two companies seemed a natural fit and complemented each other’s strengths. Even though it was now a subsidiary Brown & Root fiercely maintained its independence.


With Johnson in the White House after Kennedy’s assassination, Brown & Root won a contract to do $400 million worth of military construction work in Vietnam clearing out the jungle, creating landing strips, dredging channels, and building bases. Brown and Root became a symbol of war profiteering with anti-war protesters. They could afford the criticism. By now they were the number one construction company in the US with sales of $1.6 billion. But the retirement of Johnson and the death of George Brown saw a downturn in their fortunes. In the 1980s the workforce declined from 80,000 to 20,000. They needed another war to turn around their fortunes. Iraq was to provide the excuse in 1990.

Halliburton won a Kuwaiti oil cleanup contract and Brown & Root won an additional $3 million contract to assess war damage. Back in the good graces of the government, Brown & Root found further work in Somalia in 1993. Their big pay day arrived in Clinton era with the Logistics Civil Augmentation Program (LOGCAP) Logistics Civil Augmentation Program (LOGCAP). A report commissioned by the Pentagon (and written by Brown & Root) suggested they use one contractor to handle all of its contingencies to provide logistical support in case of further military action. The authors of the report went on to win the bid called “the mother of all service contracts”.

Brown & Root became so integral to the army’s operations that when they lost the contract in 1997 to rivals Dyncorp the army found it impossible to dislodge Brown & Root from its work in the Balkans and carved out a new contract specifically for the area. In 2001 Brown & Root won the overall LOGCAP contract again, this time for ten years. By now it was known as Kellogg Brown Root (KBR) after it was merged with engineering company M. W. Kellogg Company which was also purchased by Halliburton in a merger with Kellogg’s parent company Dresser.

In his previous role of Defence Secretary under George Bush snr, Dick Cheney had created the conditions for KBR’s massive defence contract by pairing down the logistical wing of the armed forces. This not only freed up troops to do the fighting, it was also a handy PR tool whenever the US sent forces abroad as more contractors meant a more palatable troop number count. When appointed CEO, he got the company into the Balkans theatre of operations and earned $2 billion for the company. In his tenure, KBR’s government contracts doubled. But he also left problems. He claimed ignorance of the merger partner Dresser’s entanglement in Iraq’s Oil for Food program. When he left to become Bush jnr’s running mate, he left with a golden parachute payment and cashed in stock options of more than $30 million.

By 2001, KBR had their second Vice President in their pocket. They won the contract to build Guantanamo Bay detention centre, built Afghan bases in Kandahar and Bagram and were ready to follow the troops into Iraq. Unsurprisingly they won a $1.2 billion contract to repair the southern Iraqi oilfields. But there was trouble brewing. A Dresser subsidiary was fighting off bankruptcy over asbestos claims. KBR was under fire for its huge ‘no bid’ contracts and Cheney’s lingering ties to the company. They were accused in congress of inflating prices for importing gasoline into Iraq.

Halliburton responded to the crisis by moving their corporate HQ to Dubai and divesting ownership of KBR. In February 2007, Halliburton announced it had approved the plan to dispose of its KBR assets through a split-off exchange offer to Halliburton’s stockholders. Today KBR employs 50,000 people worldwide and remains the world’s largest defence services providers. Bush and Cheney’s “wargasms” have been very good for business.

Saturday, February 02, 2008

Adelaide throws the baby out with the backwater

The long-time rivalry between Victoria and South Australia was stoked up earlier this week by Victorian Premier John Brumby’s offhand comment that Adelaide was a ‘backwater’. The comment hit home hard in the South Australian capital and has been the subject of intense media attention all week. Brumby made the remark while discussing the possible consequences of stopping the controversial Port Phillip Bay channel dredging project.

The Port of Melbourne wants to dredge the bay to allow bigger and more heavily laden ships to enter Port Phillip Bay, but the environmental effects of the project are still in question. The project was called into doubt after the head of the ANL shipping company said dredging should not include the mouth of the Yarra River. Brumby claimed that unless Victoria pushed ahead with the $1 billion plan to deepen the channel, Melbourne would end up like Adelaide. "If you want Melbourne to be a backwater, if you want Melbourne eventually to be an Adelaide – as someone described it the other day – well, don't do this project, and Melbourne will just die a slow death," he said. The dredging project has caused deep division in Melbourne because of environmental concerns.

But the pros and cons of the dredging project were immediate lost in the firestorm over the ‘backwater’ slur. The Adelaide Advertiser newspaper led the charge back with a series of xenophobic headlines about Victoria including its "party idiots Wayne and Corey" and its loss-making Grand Prix. However a poll in the same paper found more than half of voters agree with Brumby. Adelaide Mayor Michael Harbison also concedes there could be some truth to the backwater slur. "Certainly Premier Brumby's comments have attracted a lot of attention, I think it did touch a nerve. I think there are areas that we do need to move faster," he said. "Like Melbourne, we went through a few terrible years following the collapse of the state banks in Victoria and South Australia. And perhaps we haven't pulled out of that as quickly as Melbourne.

Writing in the Griffith Review Autumn 2007 edition “Divided Nation”, South Australian writer Tracy Crisp was also keenly aware of Adelaide’s limitations. She said South Australia’s growth in the last ten years was the slowest of all states except for Tasmania. She cites Australian Bureau of Statistics figures which said SA's population would peak at 1.65 million in 2032. It will then decline and age so that by 2051 the population would be 1.58 million of which 30 per cent will be over 65. Such zero growth is a key barrier to the continued economic and social development of the state. If it isn’t a backwater now, Crisp seemed to be saying, it will be in 40 years time unless it can somehow increase its population.

Brumby himself refused to take back the backwater comment despite SA Premier Mike Rann’s demand for an immediate apology. Rann then retaliated by saying Brumby's comment was "born of Victoria's insecurity" and stemmed from losing the $6 billion Air Warfare Destroyer contract to South Australia. Radio talkback discussions degenerated into dubious rival claims about the small size of Melbourne’s fish, to the superior quality of South Australian wines, beaches, and Aussie Rules football teams.

While Adelaide media ran hot with the backwater issue all week, reaction in the blog world was mixed. Adelaide Green Porridge CafĂ© pointed out that both Melbourne and Adelaide ranked highly in a Economist 2006 global survey of most liveable cities (Melbourne was second to Vancouver and Adelaide was 6th) . Fellow South Australian resident Angrypenguin was less forgiving, calling Melbourne boorish and “the pits as neighbours”. On the Victorian side of the fence Patra’s Other Place was embarrassed and “appalled at the comments” and said politicians should keep their thoughts to themselves when it comes to other parts of Australia. More whimsically, My Big World of Crap pointed out that “one thing that Adelaide will always have though is its crown as serial killer capital of Australia!”

While South Australia raged over the slur, the news that defence contractor BAE had successful gained an exemption to state anti-discrimination laws went relatively unheralded. BAE successfully argued in the courts it needed to prevent some employees with dual nationality (including citizens of China, Iran, Syria and Sudan) from working on top-secret projects with United States contractors. The South Australian government showed no concern for the loss of rights and instead welcomed the decision. State Attorney-General Michael Atkinson said "Billions of dollars in defence contracts for SA are now assured and I think more will come to SA now that this difficulty has been removed.” Financial issues matter more than human rights to the managers of this backwater.

Friday, February 01, 2008

Don’t Read All About It: News in terminal decline

The latest British Social Attitudes report has found a serious decline in news consumption in the UK. The study released last week found the number of people who read a quality newspaper declined from 50 to 20 per cent in the last 21 years. The report which has been conducted annually since 1983 confirms what has been apparent for several years: the decline is a generational affair. In 2006, 42 per cent of 18 to 27-year-olds read a daily paper at least three days a week, against 72 per cent in 1986. The latest study also found that the internet is not taking up the slack with only three per cent of those who do not read newspapers consulting news websites.

According to Roy Greenslade in the Guardian, it is this last fact that is more worrying. While Greenslade accepts that more people will be getting their news from non-newspaper web sources, he believes there is a growing disaffection with news consumption with little inclination to follow political matters. He quotes Strathclyde University professor John Curtice who says newspapers are no longer able to fulfil their role as a news provider to those with little inclination and exist only for the political classes. According to Curtice, politicians should stop worrying about the power of the press and start worrying about its weakness.

Those weaknesses are manifesting themselves also in the US and Australia. In the US newspaper readership has been in decline for over 30 years. David Simon, maker of acclaimed HBO series The Wire, is another who worries if the news has any inherent value left. He believes that newspapers have cut themselves in the throat by dumbing down. But his criticism applies to all media, not just print. He suspects an understanding of the events of the day is no longer a saleable commodity. “Was a newspaper a viable entity only so long as it had classifieds, comics and the latest sports scores?” he asked.

Australia meanwhile has suffered two recent journalistic hits of its own. In the last week, the Bulletin magazine folded, while yesterday came the surprise resignation of last year’s Gold Walkley winning journalist Hedley Thomas from The Australian. The Bulletin lost half its readership in the last ten years, and was losing money badly. Worse, the magazine had become an anodyne cipher which presented news in an objective, but turgid, fashion. As Mark Bahnisch put it “The Bulletin appeared destined to find a graveyard in dentists' waiting rooms.” Now it has been put out of its misery, but at the cost of news coverage in Australia.

Hedley Thomas’s resignation is another bad loss to Australian journalism. He left News Corp today to take a PR job with a Queensland gas company. Thomas broke the Bundaberg Dr Death story and won his top journalism award for his coverage of the Haneef affair which was a significant factor in the downfall of the Howard Government. According to an interview with Margaret Simons in Crikey, Thomas said his job was too stressful. In 2002, he and his family narrowly escaped a drive-by shooting at their Brisbane home. Thomas told Simons “There comes a time when you don’t want to deal with other people’s problems anymore. I get dozens of calls from people who want me to investigate something, rip offs and lawyers and so on, and I used to welcome those calls and opportunities. I am just concerned that I can’t relish it for another ten years”.

While Thomas has had enough, Simons is not convinced Australians in general have lost their zest for news. In The Content Makers, she quotes the 1999 research of political academic Murray Groot who found almost 50 per cent interest in news, up 15 per cent from 1984. She pinpoints the problem that Australia is under-reported. She says newsrooms are stretched and understaffed (Thomas would bear this out), show little innovation and are driven by what has repeatedly worked in the past. She says the real reason media outlets are becoming irrelevant is that they have ceased to provide useful information. The challenge for 21st century journalism is rediscover its sense of news values before it is washed away as a corporate corpse.

Thursday, January 31, 2008

Winograd blames IDF for failed Lebanon war

The Israeli government-appointed Winograd Commission has issued a strong indictment of the military and the political administration over its conduct in the failed 2006 war in Lebanon. The 621 page final report issued by retired judge Eliyahu Winograd yesterday did not have the mandate to place responsibilities with individuals but blamed the Israeli Defence Forces (IDF) and every Israeli government since 2000 for a series of failures, shortcomings and missed opportunities. Crucially, the Commission noted Israel did not succeed in translating the military conflict into any meaningful political achievements.

The probe was dedicated to the memory of the soldiers and civilians who died in the month-long conflict that Israel calls the “Second Lebanon War”. Winograd found that the Israeli army went into battle unprepared, conducted flawed strategic planning and was unable to adjust to political realities. Among the report’s recommendations was for Israel’s government and the IDF to overhaul their strategies for making decisions during emergency situations and wars. It said there was a “genuine contradiction” between the army’s objectives in Lebanon and the limitations placed on troops due to fear of casualties. The report said “the General Staff failed to communicate to the political echelon that this manner of conduct is unsuitable for war."

The conflict began in July 2006 when Lebanese Hezbollah militants kidnapped two Israeli soldiers in a cross-border raid. Israel began a massive bombing campaign in southern Lebanon, but waited until the final days of the conflict before it launched a major ground offensive that failed to push Hezbollah out of southern Lebanon before a UN-mediated cease-fire went into effect. Before that happened Israel and Lebanon were on the verge of all-out war and several thousand people died on both sides. Much of northern Israel’s population of one million people were instructed to remain in shelters for much of the war's duration. The situation was also dire for the Lebanese as the Israelis kept up an air and naval blockade of the country until September.

After the war ended, public criticism grew as did demands for an independent enquiry into the conduct of the military, especially whether its initial response was proportionate to the kidnapping of two soldiers. The Israeli cabinet approved the establishment of the Winograd Committee in September 2006. The Commission was appointed due to a strong sense of a crisis and deep disappointment with the consequences of the campaign and the way it was conducted. Former judge Winograd chaired the committee and was joined by two professors and two retired army major-generals. The committee was tasked “to look into the preparation and conduct of the political and the security levels concerning all the dimensions of the Northern Campaign which started on July 12th 2006”. The committee began hearing testimony from witnesses from November 2006 onwards.

The committee produced an interim report (pdf) in April 2007. Its main focus was on the decisions leading to the start of the war. It found the key mistakes were the lack of a “detailed, comprehensive and authorised military plan”, a refusal to contemplate a policy of containment and a vague and ambiguous communication of the mission goals. It laid the blame on Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, the Defence Minister and the army Chief of Staff and said that had these three acted better “the outcome of the war would have been significantly better”.

But the final report did not explicitly criticise Prime Minister Olmert. He would have been relieved by its conclusion which largely absolved the political masters of the war. The report backed the decision to launch a major ground offensive in the war’s last couple of days when it was clear a cease-fire was imminent. The panel called that move "essential," even though the "last-minute ground offensive in Lebanon did not improve Israel's position.” According to Anthony Loewenstein, the very fact that the Israeli government is likely to survive the scandal “reflects the dysfunctionality of the Jewish state”. However with none of Israel’s four ruling coalition partners wanting an early election, Olmert is unlikely to face more heat on the issue.

Wednesday, January 30, 2008

America unimpressed with Bush’s last State of the Union

George W Bush defended his record in his seventh and final state of the union speech on Monday night. Bush claimed his administration had “answered the call” on issues relating to the war in Iraq and Afghanistan, the world economy and health and social welfare. Essentially Bush was talking up his record of neo-conservative military adventuring and free trade abroad while madly deficit spending at home. However while Bush was attempting to airbrush history, he introduced little new agenda in his near hour-long speech. It was also totally lacking in any attempt to address the world’s greatest problem: climate change.

Yet as usual the president received tumultuous applause. The joint houses here were applauding the office of presidency not its incumbent. Bush himself is gaining very few plaudits for his actions and is struggling to maintain any sense of relevance as the 2008 race for the White House hots up. With Bush’s popularity rating at a low 31 per cent, and second term rot setting in terminally, this year’s reception for the rehashed ideas in this speech was faint praise at best, and more often derisive and scathing.

CBS News compared how powerful Bush appeared in his 2005 speech, newly re-elected and “the most powerful person on the planet” to the “broken man” of 2008. The New York Times editorialised about “six years of promises unkept or insincerely made and blunders of historic proportions”. Meanwhile, the Washington Post also gave a damning indictment when it said Bush was “running on empty” and had “nothing new to say”. According to its political columnist Dan Froomkin “nothing he said will help bring the country together, or undo the damage he has done to American interests abroad, [or] will help him win back the trust or support of the American people, both which he lost a long time ago.”

Bush is the elephant in the room of 2008 Republican candidates who have all studiously avoided any mention of the president during the campaign. The Republicans have been on the nose since their defeat in the 2006 congressional elections. Bush exhausted all his political capital after his second election win. Most of this he squandered in 2005 with a failed bid to reform social security and a pork barrel spending binge on a highway bill. It was followed by the devastating impact (both physical and political) of Hurricane Katrina. Bush’s inept response to the crisis confirmed the impression that he was a bumbling fool. The continuing morass in Iraq didn’t help either.

This was Bush’s seventh State of the Union (his initial effort in 2001 was more of a budget speech). Messages to the Congress are mandated by Article II, Section 3 of the US Constitution which states the president “shall from time to time give to the Congress information of the state of the union, and recommend to their consideration such measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient.” George Washington clarified in 1790 that “from time to time” actually meant annually.

Until the early 20th century, the State of the Union was a written report sent to Congress. Woodrow Wilson changed this in 1913. He believed the presidency wasn’t just an impersonal institution; it was dynamic, alive, and personal. According to this philosophy, Wilson delivered an oral message to Congress. While Coolidge and Hoover both reverted to the written report, Franklin Roosevelt firmly established the modern tradition of an oral State of the Union.

In his 2008 speech Bush mentioned the word “terror” or “terrorist” 23 times. Gore Vidal asserted that the “war on terror” was as absurd as a “war on dandruff” because it is impossible to go to war against an abstract noun. In 2004 Chalmers Johnson painted a damning picture of Bush’s legacy in his book The Sorrows of Empire. Johnson's fourfold prediction is more apt than ever today. They are: a state of perpetual war, a significant loss of democratic and constitutional rights, a system of glorification of the military, and economic bankruptcy. No wonder America is anxious to move on from the Bush era.

Tuesday, January 29, 2008

World Economic Forum meeting ends at Davos

The World Economic Forum (WEF) annual meeting closed in Davos on Sunday with a call from Tony Blair for new “collaborative and innovative leadership” to address the big challenges of globalisation, conflict, climate change and water conservation. Blair, who co-chaired this year’s five-day meeting, addressed 2,500 global political and business leaders at the exclusive Swiss ski resort. He told the closing plenary session that globalisation is forcing politic leaders to adopt more collaborative approaches. “If we are interconnected and the world is interconnected, the only way for the world to work is to have a set of common values,” he said “We have no option but to work together.”

Blair also said he expects to see an Israeli-Palestinian peace deal and a pact on climate change by the end of 2008. Sharing his optimism, Nobel Peace prize laureate Elie Wiesel demanded action on Darfur and Tibet. He made a call to "to alleviate the suffering in Darfur which has become the capital of human suffering in the world today." He also received a standing ovation when he said "I'd like China to open its doors to the Dalai Lama so I could accompany him to go to Tibet. That would be a great, great victory.” WEF founder Klaus Schwab warned that if the challenges are not addressed then “even the greatest opportunities will not be enough to guarantee our continuation as humankind if you look at climate change, terrorism, poverty."

The WEF was born in 1971 as a yearly “European Management Forum” of European corporate players initially funded by the European Commission. Klaus Schwab, Professor of business policy at the University of Geneva, chaired the gathering which took place in Davos. In 1987 the forum changed its name to the WEF in an effort to claim global reach. It now includes the most prominent transnational corporations, over a thousand of are WEF Foundation Members. Its members are mostly comprised of North American, European and industrialised Asian delegates.

The WEF aspires to be an agenda setting organisation. It is a private foundation that meets regularly but has no formal policy making power unlike similar groups such as the World Trade Organisation (WTO). Both however have supranational structures that Andrew Calabrese called representative of a “post sovereign era”. When the WEF Asia Pacific meeting met in Melbourne in 2000, it was the target of a major demonstration by S11 protesters concerned with issues relevant to the expansion of global capitalism such as its apparent lack of accountability, its environmental impact and international debt structures that hamper third world development. But while they captured media attention, neither the protesters nor the WEF succeeded in engaging in debate with each other’s views.

Australia was represented at this year’s talks by Trade Minister Simon Crean. He said the forum gave renewed impetus to the long-running Doha round to open up world trade. He told a news conference there were still big gaps among rich and poor countries, but ministers had agreed to finish the round as soon as possible with revised negotiating texts for agriculture and industrial goods. "It was a positive outcome from Davos" he said. “I'm encouraged by the response and the way that message has been conveyed back here and the momentum that that's hopefully generated.”

One of the themes to emerge from the 2008 conference was a quest to determine the values that underpin globalisation. The WEF has left behind its early market fundamentalism and is now charting a new course for global capitalism. This means enhanced “market discipline”, proactive crisis suppression and a recognition of the social cost of a rampant unchecked world economy. It is starting to reach out to parts of the world excluded from its social contract including Africa and Latin America as well as inviting NGOs to participate. According to Daniel Yergin, Chairman of Cambridge Energy Research Associates (CERA), “globalisation is not going to go away.” The question, he said “is what kind of globalisation do we have.”

Monday, January 28, 2008

Congo presses ahead with Grand Inga Dam

When Zambia was hit by its second electricity blackout in 48 hours last week, it turned to its unlikely major power importer to solve the problem: the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC). The DRC is more commonly known for its interminable problems due to long-running war but is looking towards the mighty Congo River’s power generating capacity to forge a major new export industry for much of Southern Africa. Although Zambia has three hydro power stations of its own, it relies on the DRC to overcome a shortfall.

The key to the DRC’s long-term prospects in this industry is the long promised Grand Inga dam on the lower Congo. When it is delivered, the Grand Inga will be the world’s largest hydropower scheme. It is also envision by the international economic community to link into a power grid across Africa that will spur the continent's industrial economic development. Grand Inga has the potential to produce up to 39,000 MW of electricity, over twice the power generation of Three Gorges Dam in China, up to a third of all Africa’s current needs.

The major problem is the price tag: $US80 billion, well beyond the infrastructure budget of a poor African country. The scheme requires an international approach. Grand Inga is listed as a priority project of the Southern Africa Development Community (SADC), the New Partnership for African Development (NEPAD) and the World Energy Council. Meanwhile other groups are proceeding with their own plans. Three days ago, South African company Eskom and the UN environment agency UNEP presented a $50 billion plan to dam the lower Congo. It is unclear whether this cheaper option included schemes to divert water to dryer regions south and north of the humid Congo Basin. Nor have Eskom revealed the local environmental consequences.

The Congo River has long been recognised for its damming potential. When the country prepared for independence in the late 1950s, its political leaders recognised that modernisation of the country required massive amounts of electricity for factories, cities, hospitals and schools. Its leaders decided to build a dam to span the river at one of the 32 cataracts on Livingstone Falls between the capital Kinshasa and the Atlantic Ocean. The narrow gorges within the Falls create pressures within the river capable of generating waves 12 metres high followed by whirlpools strong enough to suck trees under water.

In 1972 under the dictatorship of Mobutu Sese Seko, the first hydroelectric dam opened at the city of Inga, about 55km upriver from the seaport of Matadi. Known as Inga I, it was joined by Inga II a few kilometres away in 1982. The dams not only enabled Mobutu to control the flow of power to the rebellious province of Katanga but also remain the only extant hydroelectric dams in the country. They span the river where it narrows, plunging its way through a gorge. While they have been instrumental in supplying electricity to the people of the Congo basin, they represent just six per cent of the river’s potential hydroelectric capacity and there remains 30 other unexploited cataracts.

The idea of the Grand Inga megadam has been around since Inga II was completed. The likely cataract for the dam has a drop of almost one hundred metres promising a huge amount of energy. The dam has been slow getting off the ground while the DRC has been entrenched in war. Now as peace emerges, the plans are being dusted down again. However critics are worried by the environmental consequences. The size of the dam will create a massive reservoir of water that will flood forests and farms and also prevents migration of fish while killing millions of them sucked into the blades of the turbines. The World Wildlife Fund has warned that as conflict in the region subsides, a hydropower development presents the greater threat to the freshwater biodiversity of the Congo Basin, one of the most important wilderness areas left on the planet.

The dangers inherent in the potential size of Grand Inga is also shared by the World Rainforest Movement (WRM). They argue that because the Congo River runs strongly all year (due to rains on both sides of the equator) no large dam is needed. They say that to connect Inga to an Africa-wide electricity grid would cost more than $10 billion but would still not reach the hundreds of millions of Africa's rural poor. The Inga project departs from the goal of small-scale sustainable energy projects which would bring electricity to rural people through local wind and solar power projects. According to WRM, megaprojects are more likely to bring social, economic and environmental disruption of people’s livelihoods, lands and life.

Sunday, January 27, 2008

Suharto dies

Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has declared a national week of mourning after former long-term president Suharto finally died today following a long illness. The 86 year old Suharto was admitted to hospital on 4 January with failing kidneys, hearts and lungs. Doctors prolonged his life through dialysis and a ventilator, but he stopped breathing on his own overnight before slipping into a coma today. He died of multiple organ failure. Suharto dominated Indonesian politics from his accession to power in 1967 until he was forced to resign in 1998. While Indonesia mourns the passing of a respected leader who improved the country’s standing in world affairs, the reaction in the rest of the world is likely to be more mixed reflecting Suharto’s long, brutal and graft-ridden regime.

Suharto grew up in central Java and was trained in the military by the Japanese during their occupation of the Dutch East Indies in World War II. He then fought the Dutch at the end of the war and served in the new national army after independence in 1950. He rose though the ranks to be one of the most senior military leaders by the mid 1960s. In 1965 Suharto began the process of a brutal seizure of power from Indonesia’s first president Sukarno with the help of the CIA after the Americans believed Sukarno’s so-called “guided democracy” was leading the country down a likely Communist path. In the purges that follow, somewhere between 300,000 and million suspected Communist supporters were murdered on Suharto’s orders. Sukarno was finally stripped of power in 1967 and Suharto was elected president a year later.

Suharto ruled with in totalitarian fashion and posted soldiers in every village. On economic matters, he relied on a group of American-educated economists, nicknamed the "Berkeley Mafia," to set policy. Together they succeeded in delivering at least 7 percent annual economic growth for three decades. He initiated a successful family planning program that, unlike China, did not rely on coercion. The Indonesian economy was opened up to foreign investment, and became a darling of the World Bank and at the International Monetary Fund. Yet Suharto and his children also built up assets estimated at $30 billion in 1989.

Suharto was finally undone by the Asian financial crisis of 1997. In early 1998 he was re-elected president seventh time unopposed. This time Jakarta erupted with pro-democracy riots. 2,000 people were killed and 5,000 buildings were destroyed in Java and Sumatra. Troops secured the airport and government offices and schools were closed while 30,000 students occupied the government buildings. Suharto attempted to face down the protesters. However General Wiranto stepped in and urged him to reconsider. Finally the wave of domestic and international pressure told and Suharto reluctantly stood aside. Suharto retired to a family compound in Central Jakarta, making few public appearances.

The Indonesian military has guaranteed the safety of the Suharto family and its ill-gotten gains of tens of billions of dollars. Armed forces commander and then Minister of Defence Wiranto gave the guarantee to the family when Suharto gave up the presidency in 1998 and it has been honoured by all his successors. Despite his departure, the Suharto family continued to lead the predator class along with its corporate and banking cronies. They operated a system of “plunder by corruption” aided and abetted by senior bureaucrats, state industry executives, police, army generals and a “court mafia” of compliant judges, prosecutors and officials.

Under the reformasi program of President Wahid, Suharto’s son Hutomo (known as Tommy) went to jail for ten years for arranging the murder of a judge who sentenced him to eighteen months for his role in a land scam in September 2000. Also in 2000, Suharto himself was placed under house arrest while authorities investigated his regime’s corruption. But Suharto was saved when court-appointed doctors announced that he could not stand trial because of his declining health. State prosecutors tried again in 2002 but then doctors cited an unspecified brain disease. The last few years have been a long slow decline interspersed with continual legal wrangling.

Saturday, January 26, 2008

Bennelong Time: Australia Day

On a sunny day in Adelaide, Australia’s cricketers held the upper hand against India on the third day of the fourth test despite the surprise retirement announcement of wicket keeping great Adam Gilchrist. It was a double national celebration at the Adelaide Oval, possibly the most aesthetically pleasing sporting ground in the world. Not only was it Australia Day, the 220th anniversary of the first European settlement landing in Sydney Cove, but it was also Republic Day in India. That holiday celebrates the day in 1950 the constitution of India came into force and India became a truly sovereign state some two years after it gained independence. While both Australian and Indian celebrations are artificial constructs, the mood was happy in Adelaide and elsewhere. Any excuse for a celebration is a good one.

However for the original Aboriginal settlers of Australia, today is the Day of Mourning when their traditional way of life was ended. Ironically their day celebrates its own special anniversary, being the 70th anniversary of the first organised protest against the treatment of Aboriginal people around Australia.

In 1992 then PM, Paul Keating made a speech in the Sydney suburb of Redfern that seemed to herald a new era of white-Aboriginal relations when he recognised the issues started with non-Aboriginal Australians. Redfern was not only a suburb where Aboriginals lived it was also “[j]ust a mile or two from the place where the first European settlers landed”. Yet just over three years later Keating's vision was comprehensively rejected. John Howard was elected on the manifesto of making white Australians feel more comfortable about themselves. His attitude is reflected today in the advice of such bloggers as Iain Hall today to “enjoy this day without shame.”

But the story has more to do with positive recognition than negative shame. It was never in doubt what was going to happen when 18th century Europe collided with the Neolithic society it encountered in Port Jackson on 26 January 1888. If the British hadn't started it, it would have been the job of the French fleet of Comte Jean-François de Galaude La Perouse who by astonishing coincidence entered Sydney Harbour that same morning 220 years ago.

But it was the First Fleet of Governor Arthur Phillip who had the honour of starting the colony. Phillip was a doughty 50 year old experienced Royal Navy officer. He was smart enough to know that the original landing point at Botany Bay six days earlier was unsuitable for a settlement. And so they jettisoned the Bay discovered by Cook in 1770 and found a harbour 20km to the north of incredible beauty. His ships brought a cargo of a thousand men and women and they found fresh water in what is now Sydney Cove from a creek that ran through gum trees and trickled over mudflats into the saltwater cove.

But Phillip and his fleet knew they weren’t coming into an empty landscape. On the way into the harbour, they were alerted to the firestick farming practices of the native population. Four days earlier, a landing party on the ocean side encountered an armed and vociferous group of locals. As Phillips later described it to the admiralty, the native’s “confidence, and manly behaviour made me give the name of Manly Cove to this place”.

Sydney Cove also had its manly natives. Sydney was the home of the Eora people. They lived in the region for tens of thousands of years having slowly migrated south from the landbridge with Asia. Eora simply meant “the people” and that is how they described themselves to Phillip. They would have had advanced notice of the European arrival from messengers bringing news about the Manly encounter. However they did not offer any opposition to Phillip and instead were very friendly.

British soldiers who had served in the Americas such as Watkin Tench called them “Indians”. While the natives chanted, the convicts were rowed ashore and ordered to cut down trees, clear the ground and pitch tents. North shore natives helped the crew catch fish. But while Phillip named the cove for the British home secretary Thomas Townesend (otherwise known as First Viscount Sydney), the Eora had their own names for the area. Sydney Cove was Warrane which was protected by Tallawoladah (now The Rocks) to the west and Tubowgule to the east. Tubowgule now has a different Aboriginal name Bennelong Point and is also the site of a half-decent Opera House.

The point is named for Woollarawarre Bennelong, a wangal man, from a clan name meaning ‘west’. Wangal territory ran from Parramatta to Darling Harbour. Although kidnapped by Phillip and not immune to Stockholm Syndrome, Bennelong proved to be a clever and wily politician who played a double game in his relations with whites. Phillip kidnapped him in 1790 in order to gain an insight into the Eora mind and calm the increasing tensions between the old and new settlers. Although he learned English and struck up a personal friendship with Phillip, Bennelong escaped after five months. He took part in a spirited resistance against the whites. It is likely he organised the spearing of Phillip in a ‘payback’ exercise for the kidnap. Phillip refused to blame his black protĂ©gĂ©. He was rewarded in December that year when Bennelong and his kinsmen and women came in peacefully to Sydney Town, devastated by the newly introduced disease of smallpox.

When Governor Phillip returned to England in triumph in 1792, he took with him Bennelong. At first the young Aboriginal man enjoyed his stay in London, dressed as a dapper gentleman in a ruffled lace shirt and fancy waistcoat. He met mad King George III, heard debates in parliament and swam in the Thames. Newspapers treated him as a “merry fellow” and a celebrity who was “delighted with everything he sees, and courteous to those who know him”. But after seven months he wanted to go home and returned to Sydney broken by the coldness of British weather.

On board HMS Reliance his lungs gave him trouble but he was well enough to teach words of his native tongue to the future explorers Matthew Flinders and George Bass. But Bennelong was a beaten man. When he got home he abandoned most of his white ways except for one – alcohol. He took seriously to drink and violence and was frequently wounded in payback battles. Bennelong died in January 1813 (almost 25 years to the day of the first settlement) at James Squire’s orchard in Parramatta.

Bennelong’s legacy today lies mostly in his name. As well as the famous building on the point that bears his name, he also survives in the nation’s most volatile federal political seat (in inner West Sydney) that in November saw sitting Prime Minister John Howard famously defeated by Labor’s star media recruit Maxine McKew.

But Bennelong’s people have not done so well as his name. Australia's indigenous population has suffered a genocidal history that caused the Aboriginal population to drop from 300,000 to 70,000 in the 134 years to 1920. Australia Day remains a tainted holiday until white Australia remembers the act of recognition in Keating’s Redfern speech. It also requires an act of imagination: As Keating said, “We cannot imagine that the descendants of people whose genius and resilience maintained a culture here through 50 000 years or more, through cataclysmic changes to the climate and environment, and who then survived two centuries of dispossession and abuse, will be denied their place in the modern Australian nation.” Happy Australia Day.

Friday, January 25, 2008

North Kivu peace deal

The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has issued a cautious welcome for the peace deal struck in the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) province of North Kivu. UNHCR rep AntĂłnio Guterres told the signing conference in Kivu’s capital Goma it represented a big step in the search for a lasting peace but would not end the immediate problems. Guterres’ caution is understandable given the tenuous nature of previous agreements. The situation in North Kivu remains volatile with 800,000 displaced people still seeking refuge despite the Congolese war ending officially in 2003.

DRC president Joseph Kabila attended the signing in Goma, a city which has suffered heavy fighting in recent months. The UN and western governments exerted heavy diplomatic pressure to get the peace deal to the table and now hope the accord can put an end to fighting in the east, which has raged on despite the official end of Congo’s war five years ago. Last minute disagreements over war crimes cases threatened to derail the talks but the deal was finally sealed on Wednesday.

As well as the DRC government, the deal was signed by Tutsi rebel General Laurent Nkunda, the pro-government Mai Mai militia and about 18 other minor groups. The accord brings long negotiations to an end and includes an immediate ceasefire and the deployment of UN peacekeepers in 13 key locations. It also offers a probable amnesty to Nkunda and his forces however the rebels say the full implementation will require the disarming of a rival ethnic Hutu militia.

The signature of Laurent Nkunda was a key success factor. His forces have clashed with government troops since 2004 and he has been successful in painting himself as a protector of Congo’s Tutsi minority especially from the remnants of the Hutu Interahamwe militia (known as ex-FAR) who were responsible for the 1994 genocide in Rwanda. Nkunda helped Joseph Kabila overthrow the hated Mobutu reign but fell out with the new Kinshasa regime. The DRC and the UN issued an arrest warrant for Nkunda in 2005 but that has been nullified by the new deal.

Nkunda’s forces have been mainly fighting the government aligned Mai Mai who have been equally as brutal. Both sides use child soldiers indiscriminately. The Mai-Mai are a loosely aligned local defence group of pro-government forces made up of warlords, traditional tribal elders, village heads, and politically motivated resistance fighters. In 2006, Human Rights Watch called for the DRC government to charge Mai Mai warlord Kyungu Mutanga on counts of murder, rape and abuse of civilians.

Analysts are sceptical the latest deal can achieve much as the talks excluded two key players: Rwanda and the Hutu Interahamwe (ex-FAR). Those displaced by the conflict want to see the repatriation to Rwanda of members of Hutu extremist militias they regard as the main cause of insecurity in the region. The DRC government has tabled a plan that provides for the repatriation of Rwandan Hutu fighters, first voluntarily and then by force from mid-March if they refuse to leave. But most of the people in North Kivu are hopeful the deal will bring peace to a devastated region. "There are too many killings, too many rapes and abuses that should stop at all costs," said local farmer Alphonse Batiburasabinako. Up to 1,500 Congolese die in the region every day, mostly from preventable diseases and malnutrition.

The news comes just days after the International Rescue Committee released its report into "Mortality in the DRC" (pdf) over the last ten years. The report notes that although a formal peace accord was signed in December 2002, the war has since given way to several smaller conflicts in the five eastern provinces including North Kivu. The IRC’s earlier four studies, conducted between 2000 and 2004, estimated that 3.9 million people had died (mostly from disease and malnutrition) in the DRC since 1998, making it the world’s deadliest conflict since World War II. This fifth survey, covering the period from January 2006 to April 2007, found the DRC’s national crude mortality rate (CMR) of 2.2 deaths per 1,000 per month is 57 percent higher than the average rate for sub-Saharan Africa. This is despite recent improvements. Once again it found most deaths are due to preventable and treatable conditions. The IRC says recovery from conflict is a slow and painful process. They called on steadfast international commitment to secure recent gains and prevent further deterioration in a country that remains in deep need.

Thursday, January 24, 2008

The Bully leaves the playground: The Death of The Bulletin

Australia’s oldest magazine "The Bulletin" has shut down today after 128 years. Australian Consolidated Press (ACP) magazines chief executive Scott Lorson issued a media release today saying that The Bulletin would cease publication immediately. Its final issue went on sale yesterday. In the latest Audit Bureau of Circulations figures, The Bulletin was down to 57,000 readers down from circulation highs of over 100,000 in the mid 1990s. The news comes barely three days after Lachlan Murdoch and James Packer launched a bid for the PBL media empire which includes 25 per cent of ACP.

However with The Bulletin always being a pet project of James Packer’s late father Kerry, the decision to shut down the magazine is more likely to have been made by the other 75 per cent owning partners, Swiss private equity firm CVC Asia Pacific Ltd. Journalists union Media Entertainment and Arts Alliance (MEAA) blames the former Howard Government’s change to media laws that allowed Packer to sell out PBL to overseas interests. Union federal secretary Chris Warren said CVC Asia Pacific was only interested in short-term profits. "Instead of The Bulletin being owned by an Australian company, it's now controlled by overseas private equity," he said. "It's only interested in money and not really understanding I think the important role that many of the assets within that company play within the broader Australian culture."

There is no doubt the “Bully” has played a major role in Australian culture. According to founding editor Jules Francois Archibald (for whom the Archibald Prize is named), the Bulletin began with a rickety three-legged chair which upended him on his first meeting with fellow founder John Haynes in a Sydney newspaper office in 1879. The two men were determined to start a paper of their own. The Sydney Bulletin (named for the San Francisco Bulletin) first hit the newsstands on 31 January, 1880 with a circulation of 3,000. According to Sylvia Lawson its early years were an “astounding conflagration of cultural and journalistic energy”. She says its racist and xenophobic jokes were merely elements in a weekly cacophony of news, anecdotes, stories, ballads and pictures.

John William Traill became editor in 1883 and he really put the paper on its feet. After a shaky start its circulation grew to 80,000 in ten years. He promoted an anti-British line in the 1886 adventure in the Sudan and supported Parnell and the Irish home rule cause. It celebrated the centenary of white Australia in 1888 as “the day we were lagged”. But xenophobia was never far away and The Bulletin ran a hysterical campaign against Chinese immigration. The Bulletin was a major influence on the White Australia policy implemented by the first federal government in 1901.

The Bulletin played up to its nickname of the Bushman’s Bible. Its correspondents Henry Lawson (pictured right with Archibald) and A.B. Patterson engaged in a famous verse-duel on the bush, with Banjo singing its praises and Lawson reciting its glooms and hardships. But by Federation, the newspaper was past its early best. Archibald left the paper in 1906 and it moved further to the right editorially. The paper suffered a long and unloved decline. By mid century the readership had dwindling to near non-existence. It was saved from death by the purchase in 1960 by Frank Packer’s ACP. Packer’s masterstroke was to appoint Donald Horne as editor. Horne revitalised the Bulletin, excised its xenophobia and mysogyny and removed the controversial masthead which read ‘Australia For the White Man’.

Despite Horne’s energy and intellectual vigour the magazine continued to operate at a loss for many years. It was sustained only by Packer largesse and its tax write-off potential. However, in the 1980s The Bulletin was shifted to a more business-oriented audience and did well in the financial boom. Its circulation topped 120,000 and became a profitable title once more. But it suffered at the hands of the free magazine inserts in the weekend newspapers and again later at the hands of the Internet.

Various attempts to breathe new life into the magazine failed. Laurie Oakes has written a political column in The Bulletin for the past 24 years. He lamented the decision to shut it down, but said it was not a shock. "I know that it hasn't been profitable for a long time and I guess when you think about it, it's not surprising,” he said. “It doesn't make it any less upsetting.”

Wednesday, January 23, 2008

Ominous Scions: Murdoch and Packer plot Australian media's future

The two most dominant names in Australia media came together again this week when Lachlan Murdoch and James Packer announced a $3.3 billion bid to take over Consolidated Media Holdings (CMH). Packer's Consolidated Press Holdings (CPH) is the major shareholder in CMH and they are combining with Murdoch’s private company Illyria to buy out the remaining shareholders. The deal is contingent on whether CMH shareholders consider the $4.80 share price adequate.

If the deal is approved, Murdoch will become the newly privatised vehicle's executive chairman. He has declared he wants to take on a “hands on” role. He said the main attraction is the growth potential in the Pay TV assets but he also wants to get involved with Channel Nine as well. "This is going to be my focus over the years to come if we're successful," he said. "I ran 35 TV stations in the US while I was there, obviously I understand print businesses very well, so I'd hope I could I add value if CVC and the management of PBL Media were interested in my opinions.”

It is his reference to the newspaper business that worries many analysts. Murdoch vehemently denies his side of the funding is related to his father Rupert’s massive News Corp organisation which is already the largest media empire in Australia. Murdoch jnr resigned from his executive positions at News Corp in July 2005 but remains on the international board in a non-executive capacity. Murdoch said he had no plans to leave the board, because CMH businesses didn't compete with News Corp operations. Writing in Crikey today, Glenn Dyer asked where the money was coming from to finance the bid and suggested banks were coming to the party because Rupert Murdoch has provided guarantees for his son’s share.

Also writing in Crikey, Margaret Simons has similar concerns. She questioned whether Lachlan Murdoch can, as he claimed, “add value” to the assets. She says there must be more to the deal than is currently in the public domain as asset strength is not a primary consideration for venture capitalists. Simons believes that Murdoch’s most important weapon is his “contact book” which he has extraordinary leverage over through his family.

Certainly the assets in question are extremely valuable. CMH was formed just three months ago when Packer split up his father Kerry’s Publishing and Broadcasting Limited (PBL) empire into a media and a gaming arm based on the Melbourne Crown casino. At the time Packer pumped most of his cash into the gaming side of the business. Despite his divestment, CMH remains a big player in the Australian media scene. It owns 25 per cent of the Nine Network, Pay TV operator Foxtel, and Australia’s biggest magazine publisher ACP (publisher of the titles Women's Weekly, The Bulletin and Woman's Day). It also has an option to buy-out the remaining 75 per cent of these assets if private equity owners CVC decide to sell out. CMH’s grab-bag of enterprises led the Australian Financial Review’s Chanticleer to describe it as “Spare Parts Media”, an organisation unlikely to last long as investors eye off its strategic assets.

Murdoch and Packer will be hoping this will be more successful than their last joint venture. They were both directors of the ill-fated telecommunications company One.Tel which collapsed in 2001. During the dotcom boom One.Tel attempted to create a youth-oriented image to sell their mobile phones and internet services. The company was supposed to make the country's richest sons successful in their own right. In 2000 One.Tel reported a loss of $291 million after spending over $500m million on purchasing additional Australian spectrum licenses. Yet company managers Jodee Rich and Brad Keeling gave themselves a $7 million dollar bonus. Packer defended the pair as visionaries and excellent managers. In May 2001, Packer and Murdoch underwrote a rights issue of $132 million worth of new shares. Just 12 days later, a voluntary administrator was sent in and One.Tel went bust. One can assume the pair have learned their lesson and won’t ignore their statutory duties of care and diligence a second time.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Born Again Borg: Lawrence Springborg rises from the Nationals' Ashes

In a transparently desperate and uninspiring move, the 17 parliamentary members of the Queensland National Party have re-appointed Lawrence Springborg as its leader. Springborg previously led the party from 2003 to 2006 and resigned in 2006 after his second comprehensive election defeat at the hands of Labor. He now replaces the hapless Jeff Seeney who never faced the voters as party leader. Springborg regains the leadership with the Nationals polling at just nine per cent and he is considered the most attractive proposition to lead a proposed new state-based conservative force that might emerge from the Queensland Nationals and Liberals.

The news came just a couple of days after Springborg said a leadership coup was "not on the radar" despite being approached by parliamentary colleagues to challenge Jeff Seeney. But soon-to-be-deposed leader Seeney was not fooled and knew the challenge was just under that radar. He accused Springborg of manoeuvring behind the scenes. "I'm particularly disappointed that Lawrence Springborg has chosen to pursue this issue in the media,” he said. Springborg's machinations worked to perfection and he won yesterday's vote in some comfort.

The scenario is similar to what transpired in 2003. At that time Springborg was touted as a replacement leader for Mike Horan. The Nationals were polling poorly at 8 or 9 per cent and Horan was perceived of being incapable of mounting any serious opposition to then Labor leader Peter Beattie. Springborg (who was deputy leader under Rob Borbidge) urged a party ballot and put his name forward as leader under the label of “progressive conservative”. He won the party ballot easily by nine votes to three. Then just 34 with four young children, he represented a generational shift for the Nationals. He immediate announced then (as he did yesterday) his most urgent goal was to unite with the Queensland Liberals.

Of course, that dream was scuppered at a federal level by Prime Minister John Howard. Now the ambitions are just state based. According to anonymous acerbic Queensland psephologist Possum Comitatus, Springborg’s dubious prize is to occupy one of the state’s two opposition leadership positions. He believes any merger is doomed to failure due to the radically different supporter bases of the two parties. He also correctly points out that it doesn’t matter what the Nationals the next non-Labor leader of Queensland will be a Liberal. The coalition needs to win another unlikely 20 seats from Labor to win power and these seats are in the populous south-east of the state where only the Liberals are capable of winning.

While the Possum was scathing, fellow Queensland political pundit Mark Bahnitsch conceded Springborg is “marginally better placed” than Feeney to take up the fight to Labor leader Anna Bligh (who herself has yet to be tested at the polls as leader). But that was where the praise ended. Bahnitsch called Springborg a “single note politician” due to his infatuation with the merger with the Liberals, a prospect doomed to failure anyway. Bahnitsch also castigated the laziness of the Nationals frontbench which he said was content with the spoils of opposition.

This laziness is an arrow pointed straight at Springborg himself. Tracey Arklay and John Wanna’s analysis of the 2004 Queensland election defeat was a damning indictment of his inactivity. Arklay and Wanna said that Springborg allowed Peter Beattie to run a “non-campaign”. Defending 66 out of 89 seats in parliament, it suited Beattie to avoid campaigning and adversarial politics to reduce the risk of a protest vote. However the strategy would not have worked unless supported by a compliance and supine opposition. Springborg entered the election with low expectations, failed to challenge the Premier and relied on a vain hope of a “natural correction”. The result was a second successive landslide win for Labor. Springborg didn’t do much better in 2006 against an even more tired Beattie Government. It beggars belief that anyone thinks he will make any further ground against Labor rejuvenated with Anna Bligh’s leadership.

Monday, January 21, 2008

The return of Firestick Farming

In an unsigned opinion article about the danger of fire bugs in The Age last week, the writer invoked the ancient Aboriginal practice of firestick farming. Firestick farming refers to the practice of the indigenous use of fire to promote the well-being of particular types of ecosystems. The regular burning not only kept down undergrowth and germinated fresh seedlings but also curbed wildfire by preventing dry fuel from building up. The practice has died out since the European invasion of Australia and the Age writer states this has increased the devastation caused when fire bugs deliberately light bushfires.

The term “firestick farming” was coined by Australian prehistorian Rhys Jones in his 1969 book “Australian Natural History”. His thesis is that over tens of thousands of years the practice produced widespread ecological changes in the vegetation and the animals that lived there. The fires thinned out eucalyptus forests, kept the undergrowth sparse, and promoted native grasses which in turn encouraged grazing animals such as kangaroos. The kangaroos provided a readily accessible supply of meat. Jones states that before Europeans came to Australia, the land had already been "colonised, exploited, and manipulated" by Aborigines, who "systematically and universally" lit bushfires over the entire continent. It was an integral part of their economy.

The practice was so widespread that early white navigators called Australia the “burning country”. On their way from Botany Bay to Sydney Harbour, the First Fleet noted “a great number of fires” which marked the presence of large numbers of indigenous people. They also noted the open "park like" nature of the country around Sydney Cove and Parramatta. According to Rhys Jones, early settlers in Tasmania found superb grasslands for their sheep. They were mystified when, after a few years, the forest grew back over the land. They did not realise that in hunting off the Aborigines, they had stopped the land management by fire. It was the Aborigines who maintained the grasslands. Similar discoveries were made elsewhere. While surveying western New South Wales in 1848, explorer Thomas Mitchell said: "Fire, grass, kangaroos and human inhabitants seem all dependent on each other for existence in Australia. Fire is necessary to burn the grass and form these open forests in which we find the large kangaroos."

Aboriginal burning practices are based on regular “cool fires”. Patch-burning low intensity fires occurred in winter with over a number of years to create a mosaic of habitats. Aboriginals lit fires when there was little fuel load and the weather was not going to cause the fire to get out of control. The practice also helped seed germination in some plants.

To obtain fire, the pointed end of a stick was pushed into a hole in a piece of wood and twirled rapidly in the hand creating friction. Because this was a tedious practice that took the time and effort of many men, they carried the firesticks with them wherever they went. The natives used fire to trap game, cook game, dry fish, smoke animal from trees, night fishing, provide warmth, deter mosquitoes, and cremate the dead. Through firestick farming the Aboriginals formed their landscape and forged their livelihoods.

While firestick farming was banned by the white Northern Territories authorities for many years, the practice is now making a comeback. In western Arnhem Land the local community is creating firebreaks using traditional methods. The ancient practice of burning the lands soon after the rains to regenerate useful plants and animals was ended in the last fifty years as people moved into townships. As a result, around half of the landscape was incinerated by uncontrolled wildfires late in the dry season. Now the locals have struck an innovative deal with an LNG refinery company (Conoco-Phillips) that requires carbon credits. Their research revealed that a hectare burnt in May releases half the greenhouse emissions of a hectare burnt in a hot November wildfire. For the next 17 years, Conoco-Phillips will pay a million dollars per annum to support Arnhem fire management. The carbon trade will buy the company millions of tonnes of greenhouse savings. In this way, firestick farming will prove to be economically viable as well as environmentally sustainable.

Sunday, January 20, 2008

British power in the Sudan: the story of the River War

Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir celebrated the opening of a new Chinese-funded bridge across the Nile this week at the city of Merowe, 350km north of the capital Khartoum. The bridge is the only road crossing of the Nile between the Egyptian border and the capital. Al-Bashir told the inauguration ceremony the new 440m span was an important achievement. “With China’s help,” he said Thursday, “Sudan will certainly score glorious achievements one after another along our path of construction and development.”

The Nile played a central role in the 1898 River War which established British power in the Sudan. The story is vividly told in eye-witness fashion by Winston Churchill in his 1899 book “The River War: An account of the re-conquest of the Soudan” when he was a young serving officer in the British army. Churchill himself saw action in the decisive Battle of Omdurman where the native forces were comprehensively defeated leading to the establishment of the Anglo-Egyptian Condominium which would rule Sudan until independence in 1955.

In his 1997 foreword of “The River War” Churchill’s grandson, also named Winston S. Churchill, said the significance of the book lies not in Britain’s attempts to subjugate the Sudan, but rather it is the first major work of the man who 40 forty years later did more than any other single individual to save the world from Hitler. However I disagree. The story of the colonial winning of the Sudan inadvertently shows up European attitudes towards Africa that remain today. The seeds of the modern wars and genocide in Sudan were laid in these times. There is no doubt Churchill is a great story teller and his accounts are lively and detailed. They also reveal his casual racism and his supreme belief in the civilising power of the British Empire.

When Britain decided on a mission to invade Sudan, Churchill used his American mother’s influence to get onto the staff of the 25th Lancers overriding the opposition of the Field Marshall Herbert Horatio Kitchener. Thanks to the technical superiority of the British, the outcome of the war was never really in doubt. The British built railways, took heavily armed gunboats down the Nile. Its most potent weapon was best described by the poet Hilaire Belloc who wrote “Whatever happens we have got / the maxim gun, and they have not”. Nonetheless there was no doubt Churchill’s courage. Involved in the British army’s last ever cavalry charge at Omdurman (across the Nile from Khartoum), Churchill would only have been armed with a lance and a pistol.

The most interesting part of Churchill’s story is the meticulous history of why the campaign was launched in the first place. Britain had been involved with Ottoman Egypt since the bombardment of Alexandria in 1881 as Britain defended its newest prize possession: the Suez Canal. In that typical British way, they were “invited” to give governance to Egypt and Sir Evelyn Baring (later Lord Cromer) became agent and consul-general. Sudan, which at the time was an Egyptian conquest, took advantage of the chaos in Cairo to launch a successful rebellion against their hated northern masters.

It was called the Mahdi Rebellion. The leader was Mohammed Ahmed from the northern riverine town of Dongola. Ahmed was a wandering religious preacher who cloaked himself in the guise of the “Mahdi” (prophet) who would rid Sudan of its invaders. He launched an Islamic revolution with the help of a young man named Abdullah. While the British fleet were bombing Alexandria, the Mahdi took control of Sudan. Only well-defended Khartoum held out. The British Prime Minister William Gladstone was unwilling to save Sudan but promised to relieve the defenders of Khartoum. They sent in General Charles Gordon, an old Sudan expert, to “wind up affairs” and end British interest in Sudan.

General Gordon proved to be an embarrassment to his bosses. Having fought his way down the Nile to Khartoum, he then refused to leave his post. He realised he could not extricate the garrisons. He asked for military support from Egypt which was refused. The Tory opposition lambasted Gladstone in parliament for his refusal to support Gordon. As the newspapers fed popular support for Gordon, a “flying column” was quickly assembled to rescue the city now besieged by the Mahdi’s forces. They arrived in Khartoum two day too late.

The Mahdi had stormed the city overnight and killed Gordon and his Sudanese defenders. The British mission was deemed a failure and they withdrew the field leaving the Sudan in the hands of the Mahdi. Barely five months after his campaign, the Mahdi fell sick of typhus and died. Abdullah took charge and became known as the Khalifa (successor). He would rule for the next 12 years until overthrown by Kitchener’s forces. The Mahdi’s Tomb would dominate the new capital of Omdurman, across the Nile from the destroyed city of Khartoum.

The Mahdist regime imposed the world’s strictest Islamic laws. It was a jihad state, run like a military camp. Sharia courts enforced Islamic law and the Mahdi's precepts, which had the force of law. In 1892 Kitchener became “sirdar” (commander) of the Egyptian army and started preparations for the reconquest of Sudan. With Belgian and French colonial claims converging at the Nile, it was deemed too dangerous to leave Sudan unmolested. In 1895 Kitchener launched his campaign. Britain provided men and materiel while Egypt financed the expedition. The Anglo-Egyptian Nile Expeditionary Force included 25,800 men, 8,600 of whom were British. The remainder were troops belonging to Egyptian units that included six battalions recruited in southern Sudan.

The British constructed a rail line from Wadi Halfa on the border to Abu Hamad and an extension parallel to the Nile to transport troops and supplies to Barbar. Gunboats sailed down the navigable portions of the Nile (more was passable when the river was in flood). Railhead needed to be built to cross the 7 cataracts between Wadi Haifa and Khartoum. Merowe was a significant town at the head of the third cataract where at the end of 320km of clear waterway. The army met little resistance as it snaked down the Nile by riverboat and railway.

Battle was finally joined outside the Khalifa's capital. On 2 September 2 1898, his 52,000-man army launched a frontal assault against the Anglo-Egyptian force on the plain outside Omdurman. Thanks to superior British firepower, it was a massacre. During the five-hour battle, about 11,000 Mahdists died whereas Anglo-Egyptian losses amounted to 48 dead and fewer than 400 wounded. The Khalifa escaped but died in fighting the following year. The Islamist reign in Sudan had ended. It would not resume until Omar al-Bashir took power almost one hundred years later in 1988.

Saturday, January 19, 2008

post ceasefire Sri Lanka unravels

Tamil Tiger rebels killed eight civilians and two policemen yesterday in southern Sri Lanka as the violence escalates following the end of the six-year ceasefire. The war has taken a new and dangerous turn with Tamil forces determined to take the battle to the relatively peaceful and mostly Sinhalese south of the country. The ten were killed in an ambush in the village of Thanamalwila, 250km southeast of the capital, Colombo. According to military spokesman Brigadier Udaya Nanayakkara, rebels opened fire on civilians in the village killing three and wounding three others. After they fled the area, investigating police and army troops found seven more bodies.

Their deaths bring the toll to over 300 in the last two weeks. Violence has spiralled out of control in the Indian Ocean island nation after the Colombo government unilaterally announced the end of the ceasefire with LTTE (Liberation Tigers of Tamil Ealam) two weeks ago. The latest incident happened just two days after rebels massacred civilians on an attack on a bus in a town in the same area. Attackers detonated a 20 kg roadside bomb alongside a passenger bus as it travelled through the remote town of Buttala. According to witnesses, gunmen then shot panicked passengers as they tried to flee. "Everyone that got out through the doors, they shot and killed," said 25-year-old passenger Sampath. "I jumped from the window and just escaped." 27 people died and another 62 were injured in the attack.

Meanwhile government troops have been wreaking their own havoc against the rebels as the country teeters on the brink of all-out war. Colombo claims to have launched a major offensive and killed 250 rebel soldiers in the last two weeks. There are conflicting claims about whether government fighter jets have destroyed a rebel base near the northern town of Kilinochchi where Tamil Tiger leaders were meeting. According to the pilots the base was successfully destroyed but the pro-rebel TamilNet website said the planes "bombed a civilian area with a mechanic workshop".

The government has defended its 2 January policy decision to withdraw from the truce citing “thousands of violations” to the Norwegian-brokered ceasefire agreement made by the rebels and therefore the truce itself had failed. Confusingly they also claimed the termination of the truce would not hamper the peace negotiation process. Sri Lankan Foreign Minister Rohitha Bogollagama tried to explain to reporters why this was the case: "[the end of the truce] gives us broader space to pursue this goal in a manner that involves all sections of the Sri Lankan polity, which remained sidelined due to the CFA, an agreement solely between the government and the LTTE.”

Nevertheless the real reason is more likely to be that the government believes the Tamil Tigers can be fatally weakened by a concerted attack. President Mahinda Rajapakse appears convinced that victory is near and is determined to push his troops into the northern jungles to kill LTTE supremo Velupillai Prabhakaran. Rajapakse is a rabble-rousing ultra nationalist determined to find a military solution to the problem. He has promised to hand over Prabhakaran to India where he is wanted in connection with the assassination of Rajiv Gandhi. Gandhi had unsuccessfully sent in Indian troops to keep the peace in Sri Lanka.

With both sides willing to fight to the death, there is no end in sight to the killing. The armed conflict in Sri Lanka has already claimed over 65,000 lives since 1983. Tamil Tigers have been fighting for an independent state for Sri Lanka's 3 million ethnic Hindu Tamil minority in the north and east after decades of being marginalized by Buddhist Sinhalese-dominated governments. In 2002 Norway brokered a ceasefire agreement which gave the north defacto independence and would have brought a federal-type arrangement in Sri Lanka. That prospect raised fear in the Sinhalese community that the country would be eventually split in two. Now Rajapakse is running the risk of the country been torn apart to avoid been split up.