Saturday, November 17, 2007

Cyclone Sidr batters Bangladesh

Over a thousand people have been reported killed in Bangladesh after the coastal Sundarbans area was battered by Cyclone Sidr in the last two days, with the death toll expected to rise considerably. Hundreds of thousands of others have been affected by the storms and ensuing floods which have destroyed homes and roads, caused food and water shortages and cut off power and communication links. Most of the deaths were caused by high winds which blew down trees and debris on homes. The force of the cyclone is larger than Katrina which battered New Orleans in 2004.

The cyclone saw Bangladesh hit by tidal waves, floods and 240 kph winds that created havoc in the southern cities. The capital Dhaka was still without electricity on Friday. 20,000 homes were destroyed in the hardest-hit areas and at least 650,000 coastal villagers fled to shelters where they were given emergency rations. At least ten million more remain vulnerable in the country’s low-lying coastal region.

Authorities fear the death toll may actually be much higher than the reported 1,100 dead as rescue workers have not yet reached the worst affected outlying areas. The deputy head of the government's disaster management office, Shekhar Chandra Das, said they expect to find thousands of corpses along Bangladesh’s southern coast. In the coastal town of Jhalokati 140km south Dhaka, locals told AFP of their terror as the cyclone came through. "I have never seen such a terrible scene. It was like hell. I saw dozens of tin roofs flying into the air. Whole houses too," said a local businessman Manik Roy. "About 500 of us were huddled in a shelter in a government office. The windows were shattered and it seemed the whole building was shaking.”

The category five cyclone swept in from the Bay of Bengal and roared across the south-western Bangladesh and north-eastern Indian coast late Thursday. It brought driving rain, high waves and a seven metre high storm surge which levelled thousands of flimsy huts and destroying crops and fish farms across 15 coastal districts. Tidal waves hit also coastal areas in north Chennai in India.

Thanks to localised early warning systems such as microphone canvassing and radio bulletins, hundreds of thousands were evacuated in advance of the storm. Bloggers within Bangladesh reported on the damage. Shawn at The Uncultured Project reported from Dhaka that the city was blacked out (he was able to write using his laptop’s power), heavy rain was falling and a transformer had exploded nearby. Others blogging in Bangla said “It’s raining heavily outside. Gusty winds are also present. I am still awake to face unknown danger.”

It was Bangladesh’s fragile wilderness area known as the Sundarbans that bore the brunt of the storm. The area is a world natural heritage site and home to the endangered Royal Bengal tiger. Sidr hit the eastern parts of the forest leaving a trail of severe devastation. Dr Ainun Nishat, country representative of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (IUCN), said he fears many wildlife including, tigers, deer, crocodiles, wild boars, king cobras, and monkeys might have been washed away under the weight of uprooted trees. “Sidr practically ruined the beauty of the Sundarbans”, he said.

Storms batter the coast of Bangladesh each year causing hundreds of deaths. The deadliest tropical cyclone ever recorded (pdf), the Bhola Cyclone, hit the Ganges Delta in November 1970 leaving up to half a million people dead. Another powerful storm, similar in strength to Sidr killed over 100,000 people in 1991. Most parts of Bangladesh are located in the low-lying Ganges-Brahmaputra River Delta, on average less than 12 metres above the sea level. About half the country would be flooded if the sea level were to rise by 1 metre.

Dabbling with Democracy: The Musharraf Mess

Pakistan appears to be lurching towards a dangerous endgame. While General Pervez Musharraf refuses to lift his artificial state of emergency he declared on 3 November, he has acceded to parliamentary elections in January. The question remains which of Musharraf’s opponents will be free to contest the election and the power sharing arrangement between him and Benazir Bhutto seems in tatters.

Musharraf has promised to hold elections by 9 January but opposition leaders say the emergency rule makes it a sham. The opposition parties are now considering whether to boycott the polls. Musharraf swore in a new caretaker government earlier today. The government is headed by former Senate chairman Mohammedmian Soomro, a henchman Musharraf has appointed to guide the country towards election. "We are creating history today because never has Pakistan seen such a smooth transition of government," said Musharraf. "I take pride in the fact that I have introduced the essence of democracy, whether any one believes it or not."

Not many people in Pakistan share Musharraf's blithe optimism. The interim government has been rejected by Benazir Bhutto who was held under house arrest for most of the last fortnight. Speaking in Lahore shortly after her release she told Sky News that Musharraf was an "obstacle to democracy." She said the West's interests lie in a democratic Pakistan." "Please don't be deceived because I've seen the game played," Bhutto said, "If the people of Pakistan still want me to lead them, I will lead them."

Meanwhile hundreds of students at Punjab University have protested against a students union role in the arrest of Imran Khan. The students were protesting against Islami Jamiat Tulaba (IJT) a hardline student group who captured Khan on Wednesday. Khan was making his first public appearance since the declaration of the emergency was declared. He went to Lahore’s Punjab University in Lahore, where he planned to address students. There he was feted and hoisted on to supporters’ shoulders. However students belonging to IJT emerged and bundled Khan inside a building and locked the gates. After an hour a van drove up, Khan was shoved inside driven off at high speed and handed over to police. One of the IJT students, Rashid Mahmood Bhullar, said: "Imran Khan came here and he interfered. We do not like interference from any politician."

Meanwhile Musharraf continues to interfere to suit his own purposes. He has allowed two private TV channels back on the air for the first time since the start of the emergency. Aaj and Dawn have been allowed to resume broadcast but without popular current affairs shows that have been critical of the government. Two other channels, Geo TV and ARY, are still blacked out from cable but can be still be viewed by satellite. ARY’s news director news Mohsin Raza said the government has given no indication as to when his channel will be back on the air on cable.

According to Pakistani blogger Manan Ahmed who blogs at Chapati Mystery the plethora of private channels in the last eight years have played a fundamental role in providing access to news and analysis as well as taking on the regime directly in satire and news. Pakistan’s media has risen from one state-owned and operated TV channel in 1999, to 43 privately owned and independently operated TV channels today.

Ahmed told ABC’s Media Report that since the emergency all of these channels have been blacked out. The government have allowed a couple of business channels to come back to cater for commercial interests however he said the web has not yet been affected. He said the social media and blogs are co-ordinating protests and transmitting information, including the names of those arrested, as well as their emails, letters and opinions. “They're performing a very important function, which is that they're keeping these protests from completely dying off”, he said.

Meanwhile Pervez Musharraf is now facing heavy pressure from the US to end military rule. US deputy secretary of state John Negroponte, will soon go to Islamabad today to urge Musharraf to quickly end emergency rule. ”Negroponte's message to Musharraf needs to be simple and straightforward," according to Brad Adams, the Asia director of Human Rights Watch. "If he doesn't end repression, respect human rights and restore the rule of law, Pakistan will lose billions of dollars in US support."

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Regional Partnerships Programme Audit shows political abuse

Auditor-General Ian McPhee has handed down a damning report of the government’s handling of the regional partnerships programme which has allocated over $300 million in funding that is highly biased towards government federal seats.
McPhee did a performance audit (attached in zip file) of the Department of Transport and Regional Services (DOTARS) focusing on the Regional Partnerships Programme. The report found the programme did not meet acceptable standards of public administration and found ministers regularly override recommendations to approve projects in their favoured areas. Labor leader Kevin Rudd called it “arrogant abuse” of public funds while Trade Minister Mark Vaile defended the program as delivering “fantastic outcomes for regional Australia”.

The Programme owes its existence to the 1999 Regional Australia Summit under the auspices of the then-deputy PM John Anderson. The Summit produced a number of recommendations to improve life in regional Australia. In response the Government released their “Stronger Regions, A Stronger Australia” statement in 2001. It outlined a framework for a decade-long regional development. The key direction was a partnership approach between government and the community. Its programme was designed to stimulate growth, improve services access and support planning.

Known as the Regional Partnership Programme, it was implemented in 2003 and it consolidated several disparate regional funding programs. The audit examined the first three years of operation and found DOTARS administered $330 million on the programme across 1,400 projects. In each case it was ultimately a government minister decision as to which projects got the money (In November 2005 individual approval was replaced by a committee of three ministers) according to published programme guidelines.

The main conclusions of the audit were that it was a very flexible discretionary grants programme, which assessed 1,800 requests, made 1,400 decisions and approved about a thousand of them. Individual grants ranged between $2,000 and $10.4 million and covered areas as diverse as tourism, community organisations, infrastructure works, new technologies, business grants and industry assistance. The audit noted that the programme was criticised in parliament and the media as being open for political misuse.

The audit noted that the flexible nature of the programme allied to ministerial approval presented “challenges” in demonstrating equitable treatment of applicants and said the administration of the programme had “fallen short of an acceptable standard”. However it also noted that response to audit issues had contributed to greater improvement since 2006. The audit quoted QC LJ King’s dictum in a 1999 paper The Attorney-General, Politics and the Judiciary by which ministers are expected to discharge their responsibilities in accordance with public interest and without regard to party political considerations. It also reminded ministers that they were approving the expenditure of public money.

The audit then pointed out examples that did not follow the guidelines including approvals without an initial application, “fasttracked” approvals, approvals despite not meeting approval criteria, or approvals through completely different processes. The audit concluded that these examples were less likely to be merit-based and more likely to fail to achieve the promised benefits. It also pointed out that Ministers do not have to give their rationale as to why projects are approved. Most damning was the finding that the ten largest recipients of largesse were all government held rural electorates accounting for 31 per cent of all funding. It also noted that Ministers were more likely to approve ‘not recommended’ projects in Coalition seats and more likely to turn down ‘recommended’ projects in Labor seats.

It also condemned the small timeframes allowed for due diligence, which it noted, was particularly prevalent “leading up to the calling of the 2004 Federal election”. The audit recommended competitive rounds to allow for comparison of relative merits, a more even communication process, and the scrapping of the fasttrack process (for amounts greater than $50,000). In September Mark Vaile made a National Press Club speech aimed at addressing some of these shortcomings. He limited the Programmes maximum amount to $1 million (divided into enterprise, community and small partnerships) but created a new Growing Regions Programme capped at $3 million. But because over 97 per cent of funding requests are for less than $1 million, the audit did not see Vaile’s announcement solving the problems. It recommended more accountability, ministerial justification, a more transparent bidding process and a recognition it was public money at stake.

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Wentworth A-Go-Go: The Overington Affair

The intriguing battle for Australia’s smallest and wealthiest seat has rarely left the news since the election was declared. The inner eastern Sydney suburb seat of Wentworth contains the wealth and razzle of Darling Point, Double Bay, Rose Bay, Vaucluse, Bondi Junction and Kings Cross. Its sitting Liberal MP and Environment Minister Malcolm Turnbull is a serious contender for the next Liberal leadership contest. But he is in great danger of losing his seat if the likely Labor landslide materialises. He is defending new boundaries on a slender margin of 2.5 per cent and his campaign has been bedevilled by the Tasmanian Pulp Mill decision. Labor candidate George Newhouse is a good chance to win aided by his former girlfriend Danielle Ecuyer. She is standing as an independent anti-mill candidate and is likely to direct her preference flow to her estranged boyfriend.

The complexity of this seat was turned up a another couple of notches this week. One issue was the legality of Newhouse’s candidacy which was challenged on a technicality. Under electoral law, a candidate must not be receiving payment from any government office for at least 24 hours before the formal declaration of a nomination. This morning the ABC reported NSW Fair Trading Minister Linda Burney saying she did not receive Newhouse's resignation until 2 November, the day of the nomination. The Liberals wanted this investigated. Later today Burney offered a correction saying she had accepted his nomination on 22 October though the letter was stamped 2 November. Allegations of 'smear tactics' have begun.

However for farce this could not compare with the story which was partially revealed by ABC’s Media Watch on Monday. It reported the extraordinary intervention of The Australian’s journalist Caroline Overington into Wentworth’s campaign. Overington had written several articles about the campaign commenting on the Ecuyer-Newhouse relationship as “the crashing of their feelings on the rocks of a federal election campaign” which “has become the talk of the white-hot electorate of Wentworth”. Overington also suggested the reason for the pair’s break-up may have been differences over the pulp mill decision. Overington had an ongoing email correspondence with Ecuyer throughout the campaign. In late October she emailed Ecuyer asking her who she was going to preference in the election. Ecuyer responded saying it was too early to tell.

Then Overington replied again to Ecuyer reminding her she had only four weeks to decide. Overington then asked her to redirect her preferences away from Newhouse and towards Turnbull. According to the email, Overington said “he’d [Turnbull] be a loss to the parliament and George – forgive me – no gain” signing off with a smiley emoticon. Ecuyer was not happy about the email and wrote to ABC's Media Watch saying she was “disgusted to have been lobbied by a journalist from The Australian for my preferences”. Ecuyer also said Overington offered her front page coverage if she gave her preferences to the Liberals.

Overington strongly denied she was trying to influence preferences and said the email was a running joke between her and Ecuyer. Ecuyer has failed to see the funny side and said yesterday she may make a complaint to the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC) According to yesterday’s rival Fairfax publication the Melbourne Age, Overington also said it was part of The Australian's "king-maker campaign" to play a role in the election of both Coalition and ALP candidates.

Today the Fairfax newspapers released more of Overington’s emails including ones to the Labor candidate George Newhouse. These emails showed Overington flirting with the Labor man saying “now you are single, I might even make a pass at you.” Newhouse cautiously responded that she had previously criticised him as "short, dark and Jewish" and besides, she was married. Overington upped the ante by replying “Not married, me. Separated five months ago. I might like short, dark and Jewish, you never know”. Later the exchange turns a bit more aggressive as Overington desperately sought an interview ending with “We're out the front of your house, and your office, just so you know”.

Overington's home newspaper, The Australian, quoted Malcolm Turnbull saying Overington was entitled to her opinion. "She's not part of my campaign team obviously," he said. Meanwhile writing in today’s Crikey, media commentator Margaret Simons found the whole affair “icky”. In Crikey Simons said there was “no excuse for her behaviour” and it was “out of line, and unethical”. When contacted by Woolly Days, Simons expanded on what she meant. “Although the correspondence with Ecuyer was the most legally significant,” she said, “I find the Newhouse e-mails more disturbing because of the use of sexual come-ons in the context of a relationship of power”.

Nevertheless Simons is a fan of Overington’s work. In Simons’ influential new book about the Australia media, “The Content Makers”, she wrote a substantial piece entitled "speaking truth to power", which praised Overington’s penetrative series of articles to expose the AWB Iraqi kickbacks scandal. “In 2005,” Simons wrote, “Caroline Overington held the government to account”. Overington went on to win an investigative journalism Walkley award in 2006 for her AWB stories. Now it is Overington’s turn to be held to account. Simons told Woolly Days “it gives me absolutely no pleasure to criticise her”. Despite the criticism, The Australian said it has no plans to stop Overington from writing articles about Wentworth. A News Ltd newspaper knows a good thing when it sees it: the seat of Wentworth is likely to remain a perpetual story-machine until election day.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

Politics in the Pub – Brisbane electorate candidates meeting

Woolly Days attended the Politics in the Pub session tonight at the Brunswick Hotel, New Farm. Organised by the Community Action Network and New Farm Neighbourhood Centre, the session was attended by the candidates of the Brisbane electorate with the one notable exception. Yet again, a Liberal candidate absented himself from a community forum. This time, it was the turn of Ted O’Brien who failed to make the event and "offered his apologies".

The seat of Brisbane has been held by Arch Bevis since 1990 and he won in 2004 with a margin of 3.9 per cent. Bevis is a Labor front bencher and Shadow Minister for both Homeland Security and Justice and Customs and he was one of six speakers who did attend, the others representing Family First, Socialist Alliance, the Greens, Australian Democrats and the CEC. The session was chaired by Jason Wilson of Youdecide2007.

Family First (FF) candidate Mark White was first to speak. White started off by saying a passionate society began with a passionate community. White said democracy is precious and pointed out how lucky we were compared the problems in Pakistan and Burma. He said FF protected some of the less-privileged members of our society such as those on disability pensions, those affected by Workchoices and new arrivals. He said immigrants “need our compassion” and FF does not see them as “economic commodities”. He also said the party supports an increase in foreign aid. He found it “offensive” when people portrayed FF as extremist. He said the party had acted strongly on policies such as tax deductions for first-time home buyers, child care choices, reductions in the fuel levy and is in favour of imposing a carbon tax which does not disadvantage low income earners. He said the Senate contest was crucial this time round and endorsed Jeff Buchanan as a “sensible and committed” candidate to join Steve Fielding in the Upper House. He pointed out that FF voted with the government on 110 bills out of 197 which was a 55:45 split that showed the party's dedication to balance.

Arch Bevis was the second speaker. Bevis is seeking his seventh straight term as the member for Brisbane. He began by talking about climate change which he said was the “major national issue” dominating his thinking. He said Australia had “dropped the ball” on climate change in the last decade. He said under the Keating Government Australia was a major world player in global warming discussions and the lead up to Kyoto. By the time Kyoto was signed in 1997, John Howard was in power and he argued for a rise in Australian emissions which Bevis said was “an odd thing to do”. The Prime Minister then failed to ratify the Protocol. Ten years later and Australia does not have a seat with full voting rights for Kyoto 2. Bevis pledged that Labor would immediately ratify the Protocol and pledged a 20 percent reduction in energy targets by 2020.

In health, Bevis reiterated Kevin Rudd’s provision of $2.5 billion in funding and lauded Rudd’s promise that “the buck stopped with him”. He went on to discuss Workchoices which he denounced as “unfair and unAustralian”. He said that workers in the US have better rights than here, which he said “would have been laughed at 10 years ago”. Bevis said he was a union official and appears in those anti-union Liberal ads. But he said he was proud of the work he did as a union official. He warned that the government intervention in IR law was not yet complete. He quoted Senator Minchin whom he called “one of the Liberal hardheads” as saying the government would abolish the award safety net after the election if it won. “If after 25 November John Howard is still Prime Minister,” he said, “don’t think you’ll see the end of reforms”.

The third speaker was Ewan Saunders from Socialist Alliance. He began by saying this election was historic for “lots of people he knew” that only knew a Howard Government in power. He said Rudd’s Labor were not a real opposition and “not much of an alternative” to the government. He said the Socialist Alliance was founded in 2001 as a “desperate need” for a party to stand for workers’ rights. He said they would “tear up” all of workchoices, as opposed to Rudd’s “Workchoices Lite”. He said they would also deal with climate change “the issue of the century” by reducing 60 per cent of emissions by 2020 and 90 per cent by 2030. “Tomorrow is too late to act” he said. He also said the Socialist Alliance was opposed to such measures as nuclear power, the NT intervention, the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the anti-terror laws. He said Socialist Alliance was an activist party that takes grassroots action for working people in Australia and around the world.

Elizabeth Guthrie from the Greens spoke next. Guthrie runs her own Interior Design business where she provides her clients with economically achievable and ethically sound design choices. Guthrie began with an allegory of a fire in the forest where all the large animals argued on the best way to put it out. Meanwhile while the arguments raged, a hummingbird was taking tiny drops of water from the lake to the forest to put on the fire. Guthrie said she was like the hummingbird “doing all I can” by standing as a candidate for election. She said she was unlikely to win in “a safe Labor seat” but was determined to “speak for the people in my electorate”. Guthrie said the Greens had “well rounded policies” but preferred to speak about the underlying values. “People want to be represented by an accountable, responsible government,” she said. “I’m prepared to stand up and fight for what I believe”. She finished by saying this election was “your chance to take a drop of water to the fire”.

Don Sinnamon from the Democrats spoke next. Sinnamon said that although “John Howard does not know what an apology is”, he did and proceeded to say he was sorry for the sufferings of indigenous people. He said people “were sick of the election” and the media had turned it into a litany of false choices such as Howard v Rudd and Howard v Costello. He said the election was a chance to “make our voices heard”. He decried much of the government agenda including its castigation of the hundreds of thousands of marchers against the Iraq war as “a mob”, the unfair treatment of the unemployed, asylum seekers and those in same-sex relationships. He said the silence of the ALP on these issues was “disgraceful”. He said Australia needed a Bill of Rights, citizen initiated referenda and direct democracy. He finished by saying the country “needed democracy, not a dictatorship of special interests”.

The final speaker was Nick Contario of the Citizens Electoral Council (CEC). He said that there was a looming global meltdown of financial systems due to the sub prime mortgage crisis in the US. He said Australia’s large public debt left it vulnerable and there are 1.8 million people who are ‘mortgage stressed’. He said the country was “living beyond our means because we have destroyed our means”. He said the CEC would reinstitute a government owned national bank and would restore “essential economic infrastructure” that would turn Australia into a “truly sovereign nation state not just a quarry”.

Monday, November 12, 2007

Mailer

Norman Kingsley Mailer died on Saturday at Mount Sinai hospital in Manhattan. He was 84. The cause of death was acute renal failure one month after undergoing lung surgery. Mailer was one of the giants of 20th century literature and a larger-than-life figure whose lifestyle made as many headlines as his impressive body of work. Mailer married six times, fathered eight children, and ran for mayor of New York. His towering ego and keen sense of self-publicity always kept him newsworthy. Most renowned for his remarkable collection of novels, Mailer was also an accomplished journalist, a playwright and a director, producer and actor in several low budget movies.

Norman Mailer was born in Long Branch, New Jersey on 31 January 1923 and was raised in Brooklyn. His father, Isaac Barnett was a South African Jew but it was his strong mother, Fanny Schneider, who dominated family life. Norman was always Fanny’s favourite He entered Harvard aged 16 to study aeronautical engineering. His big life-changing event occurred in an English class on modern American literature. He turned to writing and quickly had his first short story published by “Story” magazine, an important outlet for aspiring writers.

In 1943, Mailer graduated with honours from his engineering science degree and began to write a novel about life in a mental hospital. The novel never saw the light of day. Instead Mailer met and married Bea Silverman. In early 1944 Mailer was drafted into the Army and sent to the Philippines. Mailer mostly avoided the front line and served out the war as a cook in occupied Japan. But it was his single experience in combat in a patrol on the island of Leyte that was to serve as the raw material for his breakthrough novel. In 1948 that novel was published as The Naked and the Dead.

The Naked and the Dead tells the story of a 13 man patrol fighting on an unnamed Pacific atoll. The grim writing explored the sexual desires of the troops and examined the tense relationships between officers and enlisted men. It won universal critical and popular approval and sold 200,000 copies in three months. Widely acclaimed as one of the greatest war novels ever, it was criticised by some as a “Kinsey report on the sexual behaviour of the GI” and “pure army Billingsgate”. However it was less pure than they made out: Mailer coined a new word “fug” which he used liberally throughout the book as a euphemism for the then still publicly unacceptable “fuck”. Mailer himself had ambivalent feelings about the book. "Part of me thought it was possibly the greatest book written since ‘War and Peace’," he said. “On the other hand I also thought, ‘I don’t know anything about writing. I’m virtually an impostor.’”

Riding on the fame of his debut success, Mailer published Barbary Shore (1951) and Deer Park (1956) both of which were almost universally derided. Mailer drifted for much of the decade and was a heavy user of alcohol and marijuana. In 1955 he put up $10,000 to found The Village Voice with Daniel Wolf and Edwin Fancher. Mailer came up with the name and wanted the paper to be "outrageous" and "give a little speed to that moral and sexual revolution which is yet to come upon us.” Mailer soon became a regular columnist who in his first effort, promised. "I will become an habitual assassin-and-lover columnist who will have something superficial or vicious or inaccurate to say about many of the things under the sun, and who knows but what some of the night.”

Mailer quit after just four months blaming typographical errors in his column. Nevertheless the stint at the Voice honed Mailer’s undoubted journalist abilities. He was at the forefront of the 1960s New Journalism movement with Truman Capote and Tom Wolfe and he won the Pulitzer Prize on two occasions. The first time he won it for "The Armies of the Night" (1968), which also received the National Book Award. “Armies” was a journalistic novel in which he was the main character in the march on the Pentagon to stop the war. He won the Pulitzer again in 1979 for "The Executioner's Song" about convicted killer Gary Gilmore who was executed by the State of Utah for a brutal double murder.

The Armies of the Night reflected his decade-long preoccupation with, and opposition to, the American military presence in Vietnam. In 1967 Mailer also wrote “Why are We in Vietnam?” which despite the title was set in Alaska as two boys go on a last hunting trip before being sent off to the war. When the US finally acknowledged defeat in 1975, Mailer wrote in the New York Review of Books that “the responsibility for the war is entirely ours.”

In 1983 Mailer turned his attention to a different era when he published Ancient Evenings. The 1,200 page book was set in pharaonic Egypt of 3,000 years ago and Mailer spent 11 years researching the massive project. The book was blasted as dull by many critics. However Anthony Burgess included it in his 1984 collection of the “Best 99 Novels in English since 1945”. The Naked and The Dead was the only other Mailer work in Burgess’s list. Mailer topped the length of his Evenings with his CIA epic Harlot’s Ghost in 1992 which ran to almost 1,400 pages. Mailer ended that book with the promise “to be continued”.

But he was unable to keep his promise. Less than a month before he died, he published his final book called "On God: An Uncommon Conversation." The book takes the form of dialogues over three years with his friend and literary executor, Michael Lennon. Mailer remains uncompromising to the end, rejecting both organised religion and atheism. In his view there is an artistic but far from all-powerful God while humans are free to choose their own paths with a form of karmic come-uppance awaiting those who lead less than virtuous lives. But Mailer was never capable of being overly pious. "I think that piety is oppressive,” he wrote. “It takes all the air out of thought."

Sunday, November 11, 2007

An interview with Aubrey Clark – LDP candidate for Lilley

In the latest of an ongoing series of candidate interviews for the federal seat of Lilley, Aubrey Clark of the Liberty and Democratic Party (LDP) spoke to Woolly Days yesterday. The LDP is a new entry on the Australian political stage. Founded by economist and libertarian John Humphreys in 2001, this is the first federal election it is contesting. Humphreys leads the party’s Queensland Senate ticket and the party are contesting 12 of Queensland’s 26 lower house seats including Aubrey Clark in Lilley.

Aubrey Clark is 21 years old, a former overseas volunteer and student and is currently studying economic and maths at the University of Queensland. He lives in St Lucia but is contesting Lilley as a “marginal seat”. Clark says he became interested in politics a couple of years ago when he met a group of friends with a libertarian perspective who successfully changed his left-wing views. He says he is not a political person but feels strongly about the way in which social and economic liberties are being taken away from citizens.

He defined the LDP as a “moderate libertarian party” as opposed to extremists, the anarchists who see no place for government at all. Clark believes there is a legitimate role for governments to “help hold society together” but he strongly supports the “small state” principle with low taxes, the right to take drugs, gay marriage and freedom of association. Clark acknowledges that legalisation of marijuana is one of the LDP’s more controversial policies. He does not advocate its use but merely states that drug use is “people’s own affair”. He said people should have the freedom to “do what they like with their own bodies”. In the area of gay marriages, Clark believes government should not have any role in what he called “private contracts between individuals”.

Clark also believes in economic freedoms. People were free, he said, to employ, or work for, whoever they wish and do what they like with their own property. He believes in free trade and says the LDP would abolish government interference in work relations. He said there was no role for government in private contracts and also believed there should be no anti-discrimination laws. “The Government shouldn’t force people to be tolerant”, he said. Clark believed that pubs, clubs and restaurants should be free to set their own smoking or non-smoking policies and there should be no laws governing prostitution. “If people want to sell their own bodies,” he said “government has no place to regulate or restrict it.”

Clark praised the economic policy of the party founder and personal friend John Humphreys. Humphreys’ policy is outlined in his document “Reform 30/30: Rebuilding Australia’s Tax and Welfare Systems” (pdf). Clark said the policy proposes a flat 30 per cent tax rate on all income above $30,000 with a negative income tax of 30 per cent paid to any one earning below that threshold. He said the proposal was revenue neutral and had excited lots of interest from both major parties and groups such as the CIS. He admitted the policy would be difficult to sell because of the way people took advantage of existing tax rules and tax breaks such as negative gearing.

Clark saw the three biggest issues in the election as tax, social freedoms and economic freedoms. He believed that human induced climate change was a reality and something needed to be done. He said the LDP would soon release a white paper on global warming that advocated carbon taxes but he was against a carbon trading system which had failed wherever it was tried. Clark believed there was no great difference between the two major parties and said the LDP had split their preferences equally to both parties across the country.

When asked about the media, Clark said it was free to do whatever it liked. Once again, he saw no role for government in this area and was not worried that a company such as News Ltd would monopolise information. He said “everyone I know gets their information from blogs”. He said he reads The Economist (a choice he shares with the Lilley Democrat candidate Jennifer Cluse) and had faith in the fact that people will choose what they like the best. Clark finished by saying he acknowledged that some of society’s rules were necessary. “People should not be allowed to kill or steal or break a contract,” he said. “Those rules are needed to hold society together”.

Saturday, November 10, 2007

The Roo and the RWDBs: blogs of war

One of Australia’s more influential group blogs has decided to call it a day. The collective known as The Dead Roo will cease operation at the end of this month. Edited by Kieran Bennet and Rebecca Leighton with several other contributors, the Roo had a healthy audience of 100,000 hits a month and was a solid contributor to the Australian blogosphere from a leftist and Green perspective. Their natural political bias attracted the ire of many on the right of Australian politics and in their final post they discussed the difficulties of dealing with persistent criticism saying “trolls of any description suck the fun out of writing.”

The individual singled out by The Dead Roo as a major cause of angst was the Queensland right wing blogger Iain Hall. Hall is a provocative writer, open in his contempt of left-wing views and values and is always prepared to mount a thoughtful defence of his own ideas. On 8 November, Hall linked to the Daily Mail story about a hairdresser who was sued for refusing to hire a Muslim woman in a headscarf.

The story is about Bushra Noah who is suing Sarah Desrosiers, a London salon owner, for alleged discrimination at a job interview and claims she was wrongly turned down for a job she was capable of doing because of she wears a headscarf. Desrosiers does not deny this but says that Noah’s appearance would not have suited the “urban, funky, punky” image she is trying to create for the store. The case will go before the Central London Employment Tribunal in January.

Hall frames the story as the fault of the anti-discrimination laws having impact on “ordinary people” such as Desrosiers and is an example of a “Muslim activist” (Noah) attempting to change society to suit their own agenda. Yet the story does bring out a problem in attitudes. Desrosiers was keen to take on Noah after a discussion on the telephone and seeing her CV. It was only when confronted by the sight of Noah in a hijab that she changed her mind. Hall sees this as a problem of leftist anti-discrimination laws that stultifies small business. The reality is far more complex than a simple opposition of ordinary people (us) against Muslim activists (them).

Retired academic John Ray covers similar ground in his “Political Correctness Watch” blog whose subtitle “The creeping dictatorship of the Left” announces clearly its policing intentions. Ray rails daily against anti-discrimination laws, feminism, “do-gooders”, “liberals”, multi-culturalism, moral relativism, postmodernism and “mindless tolerance”. Ray is remorseless in his quest to point out idiocies that occur from time to time in bureaucratic entities, but seems fancifully convinced that every act of official stupidity is part of some giant global left-wing conspiracy.

But Ray’s gloomy influence is miniscule compared to Tim Blair. Daily Telegraph journalist Blair is also of the belief that great leftist forces are at loose destroying our society but at least his columns are leavened with humour. Blair serves his community well by being quick to point out inconsistencies in the arguments around human-induced global warming. However he is also gravely irresponsible, given his large readership (around 14,000 readers every day) if he believes the arguments he is opposed to are without merit. Blair allows his readers to feel good about themselves if they refuse to take the climate crisis seriously. Blair gleefully cultivates a sense of self-serving inertia that may seem superficially attractive but is ultimately a very corrosive and dangerous force for denialism.

Hall, Ray and Blair are all examples of Right Wing Death Beast (RWDB) blogs. Some on the right such JF Beck have enthusiastically accepted the nomenclature and use the label proudly. Tim Blair himself claims to be the first to use the phrase in 2003. Writers such as Blair, Beck and the rest are an important part of the blogosphere and act as a useful brake on the left-wing views that researchers such Axel Bruns and others have noticed dominate on-line opinion. Hall writes provocatively in the comments to the Dead Roo’s final post: “It is all well and good to desire the company of the likeminded but really in the discussion of politics that is very often very unproductive. Sadly the more rabid the writers here have lacked the courage to truly engage with their political opposites which is why the discussion here has hardly got off the ground in so many posts. Those with the intestinal fortitude to defend their leftist views are always welcome at my blog.”

Friday, November 09, 2007

Ireland may block EU treaty

Ireland is likely to be a major stumbling block to the ratification of the EU’s new treaty after an opinion poll this week found just 25 per cent of people supported the new treaty. While only 13 per cent were opposed, a massive 62 per cent of those polled by the Irish Times were indifferent or unsure of their opinion. The poll is significant because Ireland is the only one of the 27 member countries that is constitutionally bound to subject the treaty to a referendum.

All the other member states require support from the national parliament only. Irish foreign minister Dermot Ahearn said the poll showed the government could not take support for granted and talked up the merits of the treaty. “It will be about Ireland's future in Europe," he said. "I am confident that the Irish people will reaffirm their commitment to Ireland's proud place at the heart of the union."

The treaty is planned to be signed on 13 December in Portugal with ratification to follow in calendar year 2008. Ireland has yet to schedule the referendum but it is most likely to be held in May or June next year. The referendum is likely to attract ‘no’ campaigners and Eurosceptics from across the continent. All the major parties within Ireland itself support the treaty. This includes the Greens who opposed the last EU referendum, but now support this one from their position of government coalition partners.

Fine Gael Opposition leader Enda Kenny blamed the governing Fianna Fail party for the loss of public support citing the secrecy of the negotiations. They have negotiated the treaty in secret, with virtually no public debate or consultation," he said. "Nothing has been done to provide the Irish people with information about the provisions of the treaty or to explain its importance for the future of Europe."

The last EU treaty was delayed for years when Irish voters rejected it in a 2001 referendum. Ireland rejected the Treaty of Nice (pdf) which prepared the ground for EU enlargement. The Treaty of Nice was adopted by the EU to amend two earlier treaties the 1956 Treaty of Rome (which established the then-Common Market) and the 1992 Maastricht Treaty (which led to the creation of the euro). Nice’s purpose was to reform the EU’s institutional structure in the face of the significant enlargement from 15 to 25 countries in 2004. Ireland rejected the 2001 version in a poor 35 percent referendum turnout by 54 to 46 percent.

A second Irish referendum in 2003 reversed that vote, after the insertion of a treaty clause clarifying Irish neutrality. In this plebiscite, there was a concerted campaign to get out the vote, which increased to 48 per cent. It was passed with 63 per cent of the vote. In other words, the number of people voting “no” was roughly the same as 2001, but the “yes” vote was greatly increased. This was after a concerted effort by the major parties not to repeat their “limp” campaign of 2001. 39 per cent of those surveyed (ppt) who voted no in 2001 said the reason they did so was because of “lack of information”.

A similar education campaign may now be required in Ireland to see the new referendum get over the line. The new treaty is designed to reform the EU after the failed ratification of the European Constitution which was rejected by French and Dutch voters in 2005. The EU heads of government signed the Berlin Declaration (pdf) in March this year setting out an ambitious path forward to achieve unity.

While the Declaration does not mention the treaty by name, there was no doubt that this was then-EU President and German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s aim. She said updated rules and institutions were essential to ensure the Union retained “the capacity to act”. Germany wants a new treaty to salvage parts of the constitution to include a new EU president and foreign minister and simplified voting rules. They are also likely to propose new sections on topical issues such as climate change and energy. While France and the Netherlands are unlikely to place the fate of the treaty in their voters hands again, Ireland and its tricky constitution will once again become the barometer for the future health of the EU.

Thursday, November 08, 2007

Media Coalition releases damning Free Speech Report

Earlier this week the Right to Know Coalition released their report on the state of free speech in Australia. The report is a damning indictment of state and federal government policies which deny public access to a plethora of information through stifling legal provisions. The report says “free speech and media freedom[s] are being whittled away” by 335 acts of parliaments, more than 500 legal provisions and over a thousand court suppression orders.

The Independent Audit of the State of Free Speech in Australia (pdf) chaired by former NSW Ombudsman Irene Moss was presented to the Right to Know Coalition on 31 October. Its broad conclusion was that media freedom was diminishing gradually and imperceptibly. The report claimed that many of Australia’s democratic mechanisms were “flawed” and “wearing thin”. It cited poor support for whistleblowers, the lack of journalist shield laws, secrecy provisions in legislation, the “culture of secrecy” in many government agencies and numerous examples of failed or significantly delayed Freedom of Information (FOI) applications.

The report made three key recommendations. It stated the Prime Minister and Premiers should immediately issue a directive to their staff to take the laws seriously, it said that after the election the new government (of either party) should implement the Law Reform commission recommendation to eliminate the insidious use of "conclusive certificates" (pdf) to restrict access, and lastly the government should ask the Law Reform commission to redesign the 1982 FOI Law to bring it into the information age.

The media Coalition have released the document now for maximum electoral impact. The report contained several damning FOI examples such as an April 2005 request for the Defence Department to release documents on Australia’s position on rendition (not yet actioned), the results of opinion polls assessing the success of the workchoices legislation (delayed until after the election on the flimsy excuse that the government wanted to release all its opinion survey data together) and a 1993 application to the Queensland Treasurer for information about Jupiter’s Casino which took 12 years to answer. The high cost of FOI is another failure factor. The Herald Sun recently abandoned its two year campaign to seek federal politicians’ travel information after it was quoted a fee of $1.25 million – 32 person years of work, apparently.

Australia’s Right to Know
is a broad-based media coalition formed in May 2007. Its members include most of the power players in Australia’s mediascape. The initial members included News Ltd, Fairfax, ABC, Channel Seven, SBS, Austereo, AAP and Sky News. The group is chaired by News Ltd Australian CEO John Hartigan. The group released a joint statement in May which began by saying the parties had grouped together because they were “deeply troubled” by the state of free speech in Australia. They were careful to say this was not a party political issue and said all parties needed to embrace urgent reform. Their first priority was to audit the state of free speech in the country. They were concerned by the 2006 Reporters Without Borders press freedom index which ranked Australia 35th in the world.

Since the initial statement, Reporters Without Borders have released their 2007 index with Australia ranked a more healthy 12th best. Yet their annual report for Australia did not ascribe any reason for the improvement. Instead it condemned the 2005 anti-terror laws and the 2006 law on interception of communications which increased the risks of the anti-terror legislation being used abusively against the media. The report also remarked on the September 2006 High Court’s refusal to allow a journalist access to documents on the Australian government’s tax policy. It quoted the Australian Press Council condemnation of the decision which it said would give the authorities a “fresh impetus to suppress information that is embarrassing or politically inconvenient”.

The Press Council was a party to that case. The case was The Australian’s FOI editor Michael McKinnon's appeal against Treasurer Peter Costello's refusal to grant access to information on the first home buyer's scheme and bracket creep. The Council stated that in finding that the tribunal did not err, the Court failed to give adequate weight to the aims of the FoI Act, to "extend as far as possible the right of the Australian community to access to information in the possession of the Government of the Commonwealth". It said the true losers were Australian voters and taxpayers.

The case was a major spur to the setting up of the 'Australia's Right to Know' Coalition. Lucinda Duckett, a News Ltd executive and one of the driving forces behind the coalition, told ABC’s Media Report in May why they were taking action. She said that while she didn’t believe any of the imposed laws were deliberately done out of malice that the 500 legal prohibitions (now confirmed by the audit) on what can be published “form a very dangerous picture for Australia”. She said some of the biggest problems occur at state level. “Because the states are not united on many of their restrictions, and while state borders exist, they don't exist for broadcasters or for publishers, or for the Internet,” she said. “The difficulties we have as journalists, in reporting things that can only go so far and then have to suddenly stop.”

So far, neither the Howard Government nor the Rudd Opposition have made any election comment on the newly released report.

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

Zoe's Ark group tried for kidnapping children in Chad

Ten French and Spanish citizens appeared in court today in Chad charged for their role in a mass child kidnapping case. Six of the ten are members of the organisation Zoe's Ark, which was attempting to transfer 103 orphaned children from Darfur to France for foster care. They claimed they had the right to do so under international law. That claim is refuted by UN and Chadian officials say most of the 103 children (all under ten years old) were neither orphans nor Sudanese. Most have at least one living parent on the Chadian side of the crisis-ridden Sudanese border area.

Three French journalists working with Zoe’s Ark were released on Sunday. Journalist Marc Garmirian, who works for French news agency CAPA, said the group had lied about their plans and released film footage showing they had put bandages on the children to feign injury. The footage shows the convoy heading to Abeche airport in eastern Chad. Zoe’s Ark staff can be seen putting fake wounds on the children to convince officials they are evacuating them for health reasons. "You could say that they are lunatics,” Garmirian said. “Up until the moment I left the prison, [Zoe’s Ark] remained convinced that their mission was legitimate.”

Zoe’s Ark (L'Arche de Zoe) was formed by members of the French four-wheel-drive community to aid victims of the December 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami. They set up four temporary camps in Banda Aceh in Sumatra in the wake of the tsunami. The group has about 50 volunteers. Its founder, Eric Breteau, is a volunteer fireman and Zoe's Ark says it is motivated by the firefighter's spirit and sense of duty. In April, Zoe's Ark announced a campaign to evacuate 10,000 orphans from Darfur.

Its plan was to place young orphaned children from Darfur in foster care with French families, invoking its right to do so under international law. They sent a seven person team, including a doctor, a nurse and fire-fighters, to Chad. There the group sought authorisation from France to grant safe passage to the children. In August however, the French Foreign Ministry issued a warning saying there was no guarantee the children were orphans and also cast doubt on the project's legality.

On Tuesday last week, local authorities arrested 17 Europeans and 4 Chadians on charges of kidnapping and complicity. Those arrested included Zoe’s Ark head Eric Breteau. In the first hearing Breteau claimed the children were from Sudan not Chad. He also spoke in support of the journalists and aircrew arrested with him, saying only he and his fellow charity workers were responsible for the operation. The main accused face possible forced labour terms of five to 20 years.

The stakes were raised dramatically on the weekend when French President Nicolas Sarkozy became involved. He flew to Chad on Sunday and arranged to free the three French journalists and four Spanish flight attendants. But Chad’s president Idriss Deby ruled out a French demand to extradite the remaining ten accused to France for trial. Deby said justice would be done in Chad. “It is out of the question for the Chadian judiciary to abandon the case,” he said. “On the contrary, the Chadian judiciary will get to the bottom of it”.

Deby has ruled Chad since 1990 but the floods of refugees crossing the border from Darfur have destabilised his regime. Over 200,000 refugees have crammed into the town of Abeche where the Zoe’s Ark group were based. Deby has tried to maintain a neutral stance in the conflict but he has faced internal criticism for lack of support for his Zagawa kinsmen slaughtered across the border in Sudan by the pro-government Janjaweed militia. Deby survived a mutiny in 2004 and an undeclared war has existed between the two countries since 2005.

Chad claims Sudan is trying to destroy his regime by allowing Sudanese militia make daily incursions across the border. Although the two sides signed the Tripoli Agreement in 2006 to end the conflict, rebel groups inside Chad have continued their attacks on government forces. A European peace force is expected to be deployed early next year in eastern Chad to protect Sudanese and Chadian refugees. Meanwhile the war is a humanitarian crisis that Zoe’s Ark wanted to exploit. They lined up 300 families in France who paid between €2,000 and €6,000 for an orphaned child from the region. While the French families feel conned, there is also great anger in Chad. Several hundred locals gathered outside the governor's office in Abeche, where the Europeans were being held and chanted: "No to the slave trade, no to child trafficking."

Monday, November 05, 2007

An interview with the Democrat candidate for Lilley – Jennifer Cluse

As part of a continuing exercise in interviewing all candidates for the Queensland Federal seat of Lilley, this time it is the turn of the Australian Democrats. The Democrats stronghold is the Senate where they hope Andrew Bartlett will retain the seat he has held since 1997. However they are also contesting every House of Representative seat in Queensland. In 2004, the Democrats took one 1.5 percent of the vote in Lilley and the candidate this time round is Jennifer Cluse. Woolly Days interviewed Jennifer Cluse yesterday.

By her own admission, Jennifer Cluse is not a politician. She is a retiree who worked in the air force as a radio technician and then as a commercial pilot. She is a mother of two sons and lives in Chermside where her dream is to make her home completely carbon neutral. Cluse said she was compelled to put her name forward as a political candidate after John Howard won control of the Senate in 2004. Since then she has seen “appalling legislation” pushed through such as workchoices and the anti-terror laws passed almost without debate. She compared the current situation to when the Democrats had the balance of power. “We checked every line and queried every problematic bit of drafting,” she said.

Cluse said she was the classic swing voter and had elected the government in the lower house in every election for the last 40 years, except in the last one. She said she voted Democrat each time in the Senate. “Don Chipp rang all my bells and pushed my buttons,” she said. She denied that the Democrats were a spent force. “[The media] were saying we were finished after Cheryl Kernot left,” she said. “They were wrong then and they are wrong now”.

Cluse praised the Democrat Senate candidate Andrew Bartlett as an “amazingly stable, patient, and listening politician”. She said most politicians only want to talk at you but Bartlett was a great listener and he has the gift of finding a way of precisely expressing what he has heard. If Cluse had one minor criticism of him, it was that his voice modulation tends to be even and there were “no oratory flourishes”. Cluse said he was “an honourable politician”.

I then asked what she was hearing from the electorate out on the hustings. She said there was “universal agreement we’ve got to get control of the Senate back”. She hoped that people would vote Democrat, or else the Greens. She said she was not happy with the way Labor was going. “I’m starting to worry that Garrett WAS joking,” she said. She said John Howard had done “admirable things” in the past such as changing the gun laws in the wake of Port Arthur and restructuring the superannuation scheme. But against that, she said he had caused anguish for refugees, denied the problems of global warming and promoted selfishness in Australia.

She said that while the Greens were on the right path, they were not yet ‘good enough’. Cluse heard Larissa Waters speak recently where she (Waters) said they ‘had 40 policies’ now. “That was the problem", said Cluse. “They have too narrow a focus.” She said that Family First were a sinister party associated with a Church that practiced manipulation on the young people that joined it. “They are too extreme,” she said. “Balance is what we need.”

Cluse said that the environment was the single most important issue of the election. She said that she knows from her radio technician days how a runaway positive feedback situation can have dire consequences. "This is happening with CO2 emissions NOW," she said. "Electronics can control runaway positive feedback with a fuse which blows. The earth has NO fuse.". She believes we have a maximum until 2018 to stabilise our emissions though she notes that CSIRO are now saying we only have until 2015. She believed the message about this “desperate situation” was not getting through to people because of selfishness. She heard it best put in the phrase that goes “the economy is me, the environment is us”.

Cluse was depressed by the role of the local media in the election. She said she had stopped buying all local newspapers and subscribed only to The Economist. She said it was the only publication not to give the name of its reporters. The local media was all about opinion pieces, grabs, sound bytes, and was lacking in in-depth reporting. She blamed the journalism schools at universities who were commercially driven to produce what employers want. She concluded by saying that Howard had slashed education budgets and deliberately created a “dumbed down society”.

Sunday, November 04, 2007

Not an average Joh: the story of Johannes Bjelke-Petersen

While the Australian southern states settle in for the long summer evenings of daylight savings, Queensland languishes an hour behind on Eastern Standard Time. Last month, new Premier Anna Bligh ruled out bringing the state in line despite opinion polls showing the majority of Queenslanders are in favour of winding the clocks forward. Her view represents a long standing political resistance to the introduction of daylight savings that goes back to long-term Premier Joh Bjelke-Petersen. 20 years ago, Bob Hawke explained why it would never happen under Joh. “That's because he reckons the sun shines out of his arse,” said Hawke. “And he's not getting out of bed an hour earlier for anyone."

Johannes Bjelke-Petersen (“Joh” to friends and foes alike) was Queensland’s longest serving Premier and one of the most famous and most controversial Australian politicians of the twentieth century. Woolly Days has just finished reading “Joh: The Life and Political Adventures of Johannes Bjelke-Petersen”, a 1978 biography by journalist Hugh Lunn which has the disadvantage of being written less than halfway during Joh’s tenure but offers useful insights into his early days and his rise to power.

Joh was born in the small New Zealand town of Dannevirke in 1911, the second son of Danish Lutheran pastor Carl George Bjelke-Petersen and his wife Maren. The Bjelke-Petersens moved to Queensland for health reasons and settled in the town of Kingaroy in the South Burnett region. They bought a scrub-filled property they named “Bethany” and began to clear the land. Aged nine, young Joh was struck down with polio which left one leg a centimetre shorter than the other.

Joh was a hard worker and did farm chores every day before and after school. He left school aged 13 to work full time on the farm and he was driven by the desire to pay off the bank debt on the family farm. His father put the family deeper into debt by buying a second farm to feed their herd of dairy cows. It was Joh’s job to drive the cows to and from the property. He also enjoyed reading the bible and struck up a friendship with a local Lutheran pastor who allowed Joh to take the Kingaroy service whenever he was away.

Joh heard that peanuts would grow well in the sandy soils of his farm. He overcame his father's scepticism and cleared the second property to plant peanuts. Without bulldozers, Joh used teams of horses to pull the timber down. He lived in a cow bail on the property where the only furniture was a bed, a meat safe and a box for bread. The frugal cow bail would be his home for the next 15 years. Joh worked from dawn to dusk every day except Sunday and spent his evenings reading books about self-made men like Henry Ford, Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Edison.

In 1933, then 22 year old Joh talked his bank manager into lending him the money to buy a tractor. Soon he was well on top of his own work and hired his services out to his neighbour farmers. During the three to five month peanut harvesting season, Joh and his team would work all the local properties starting at dawn and finishing at 11pm working by floodlights. By the outbreak of World War II, Joh was harvesting peanuts in a big way. His record of polio meant he was unfit for service and he continued to work the land. He also moved into plant equipment business and bought bulldozers which he would clear the bush for local landholders. By 1949 he was rich enough to learn to fly. He bought his own plane which gave him great mobility for his business and eventually his political career.

After the war, the young entrepreneur was courted by the Country Party and was elected to the Kingaroy Shire Council in 1946. He was also the council’s representative on the Regional Electricity Board. The following year he stood for the vacant Country party state seat of Nanango. Joh was elected, aged 36, and he joined a parliament that had being dominated by Labor for a generation. Joh appeared in the House as a fundamentalist, and in Lunn’s word a “blinkered, Calvinistic and rural” politician. He was jeered by the Government but he handled himself well and promoted the ideas of hard work, anti-unionism and an opposition to state control socialism.

In 1952, the now 40 year old confirmed bachelor finally married. His bride was Florence Gilmour of Brisbane, the private secretary of the Main Roads Commissioner. Flo had a difficult job to “break in” the un-house trained Joh but the pair's talents were definitely in harmony. Her administrative skills balanced Joh’s political nous and they became a formidable team. Their business interests grew as they began to search for oil. But the non-drinking, non-smoking Joh remained a political outsider, even within his own party.

In the 1957 election Labor imploded due to the DLP split and the Country Party swept to power. In 1963 Premier Frank Nicklin surprisingly chose the outsider Joh to be his new minister for works and housing. Three years earlier Joh had heckled Nicklin for increasing road transport fees. Nicklin had forgiven him and noted Joh “possessed a wide knowledge of Queensland and its requirements”. In 1968 Nicklin retired and the popular Jack Pizzey was unanimously anointed his successor. New Police Minister Bjelke-Petersen surprisingly won the contest for deputy leader over more fancied opponents. But with Pizzey expected to lead for the next decade, no one made much of this victory.

Barely six months into his reign, Jack Pizzey died suddenly. Joh was elected unopposed as party leader and heir apparent to the premiership. Liberal coalition leader and caretaker Premier Gordon Chalk said he, not Joh, should have the top job. But the partners voted along party lines and Joh was elected 26 votes to 19. His first act as Premier was a reading from the Bible on George St during a Bible readathon.

His elevation to the top job meant he was now a figure of public interest. The newspapers scrutinised his share holdings in the oil industry and the mining company Comalco which suggested he had done well from government decisions. Joh held fast and refused to divest his shares. ABC reporter Allen Callaghan led the media pack against Joh and his party began to launch a challenge to his rule. In 1970 Joh stared down a party room revolt and needed his own casting vote to avoid the sack.

Things began to turn around in 1971 when Joh appointed the poacher to be his gamekeeper. Allen Callaghan became his new press secretary and his immediate task was to stop the media from seeing Joh as a loser and an inept country bumpkin. He seized the opportunity presented by the Springboks Tour. The Springboks arrived in the context of widespread condemnation of South Africa’s racial policies and their games caused riots in the southern cities.

Under advice from Callaghan, Joh declared a state of emergency which allowed them to commandeer the RNA venue (and outlaw labour strikes) and gave the police unlimited powers to arrest without warrant. The Trade Hall strikes against the Powers were condemned by the public for disruption of services and two thousand protesters were baton-charged by police on Wickham Terrace. Callaghan successfully framed the debate as a law and order issue and made Joh look a strong leader. Callaghan taught Joh the basics of television appearances. Sometimes he would stand behind Joh and give him signals when he was going off-beam.

Joh began to win the propaganda battle and he easily won the State election in 1972 with the help of the weighting of country votes in what became known as the “bjelkemander”. Despite that win, the Country Party knew they needed to make inroads in the metropolitan areas to guarantee continued success. In 1973 they merged with the Queensland DLP and one year later renamed the new entity the National Party (based on the successful NZ party of that name).

In 1972, Gough Whitlam won the Federal election and Labor was in power nationally for the first time since 1949. Joh was to become Whitlam’s most implacable opponent. At the first Canberra’s Premier conference in 1973, Callaghan turned a short sentence from Gough about petrol differentials into a price rise for Queenslanders and the Northern papers ran with this as their front page. Joh attacked the government on every conceivable issue and even the Queensland Liberal President thought he was unnecessarily provocative and antagonistic.

In 1974 the Whitlam government was one short of a senate majority and tried to alleviate this prior to the upcoming half-term election by removing one of their opponents. They made DLP senator (and the last Queensland Labor Premier) Vince Gair ambassador to Ireland so that one extra seat would be contested at the election that Labor was likely to win. But Joh got wind of his plan and put in place a ruse (known as the "night of the long prawns") to declare the election writs before Gair could formally resign. The result was that Gair’s seat was not contested and Labor would not gain the majority. The delighted opposition asked Whitlam in parliament whether he had ever “been taken for a ride” by the pilot Bjelke-Petersen. Whitlam responded by calling a double dissolution election of both houses.

That election did not resolve the impasse and Labor won only four of ten Queensland Senate seats. Joh then turned his attentins to the 1974 State election and he criss-crossed Queensland piloting his own state aircraft. Labor was virtually wiped out in this election and the Nationals vote jumped ten percent, winning some city seats. Joh was at the height of his powers. Now he could concentrate on delivering a knock-out blow to his Canberra nemesis Gough Whitlam.

The deadlocked Senate situation changed in 1975 when Labor senator Bertie Millner died at his desk in Brisbane. The political convention was that Millner’s Senate seat would go to the next man on the Labor ticket, Dr Mal Colston (a man who would later enter into Labor infamy as a ‘turncoat’). Bjelke-Petersen announced publicly he wanted Labor to put up three nominations and state parliament would choose the man it wanted. Labor refused. The Coalition began a smear campaign against Colston suggesting he was the prime candidate in a 1962 arson case.

Joh’s office then found an unlikely candidate. He was 64 year old Albert Field, ALP member and president of the Federated Furnishing Trade Union. Joh nominated Field as the Senate candidate despite the strenuous objections of Labor. Field was pilloried by the southern media and ostracised by Labor. Questioned about the Senate appointment, Whitlam described Joh as a “bible-bashing bastard”. Whitlam had gone too far. Insulting the church on TV was not a good look and there was an inevitable backlash against him. In November 1975, Governor-General John Kerr sacked Whitlam’s Government.

He and Field were defeated at the following election. Joh had seen off his nemesis Gough. Back in state politics, Joh had to ride out the storm caused by the police heavy-handed tactics in destroying a hippie commune at Cedar Bay north of Cairns. He was also troubled by the long-running inquiry that followed. Police Commissioner Ray Whitrod resigned in protest saying Queensland was becoming a police state.

Lunn’s book “Joh” was published in 1978 and misses out on the excesses of the 1980s era Joh administration. Joh trampled on civil liberties, encouraged police corruption and destroyed John Howard’s hopes of winning power in 1987 with his ill-judged ‘Joh for Canberra’ crusade. That same year, the ABC 4 Corners episode “The Moonlight State” began to bring the corruption into the public record. The Fitzgerald Inquiry released its findings in 1989 and implicated senior members of Joh’s government. Joh was eventually forced to resign. He avoided prison for perjury at the Inquiry due to a deadlocked jury whose foreman was a member of the National Party. He died in 2005 and was buried at the family property “Bethany” after a state funeral.

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Howard refuses to put out Nalliah’s fire

Australian PM John Howard has refused to cut ties with the controversial Catch the Fire Ministries despite its leader’s links the far right League of Rights group. Church leader Danny Nalliah has addressed the holocaust-denial group in 2005 (pictured) and has accepted another invite to address the league again. Nalliah has had private audiences with Howard and Treasurer Peter Costello. Howard described the League of Rights as “a bit anti-Semitic,” but said he could not be responsible for what the people he meets do. Nalliah is unrepentant. "I would not change my view. I stand by it," he told The Age. "I am a Christian minister — my task is to go after the sinner, not cast away the sinner. There is no one beyond redemption".

Grahame Leonard, the president of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, said Nalliah’s view were naive "at best" given the league's anti-Semitic stance. He also cautiously chastised Howard, who has long been a staunch supporter of Israel. “We would urge all our politicians to publicly distance themselves from the pastor and his views,” he said. The B'nai B'rith Anti-Defamation Commission and the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council also criticised Nalliah’s decision to accept the league’s invitation.

This is not the first time Nalliah has run into trouble with racial vilification. In January 2004, Nalliah fell foul of Victoria’s controversial Racial and Religious Tolerance Act in the first case before the Victorian Civil and Administration Tribunal (VCAT). VCAT found against him for vilifying Muslims. The tribunal said that he was one of two pastors to suggest the Koran promoted murder and looting, Muslims wanted to take over Australia and terrorists were true Muslims. However the Victorian Supreme Court overturned the verdict last year saying the Act does not “mandate religious tolerance”.

Religious tolerance is not something anyone can accuse the Sri Lankan born Nalliah. In 2004 he was the second person on the Family First ticket for the Federal Senate election in Victoria. During the campaign Nalliah called on his followers to “pull down Satan's strongholds”. These strongholds included bottle shops, brothels, casinos, gambling places, mosques and temples. Nalliah wasn’t talking about Christian temples, he meant Freemason, Buddhist and Hindu ones. While party chair Peter Harris distanced himself from these comments, Nalliah's rhetoric had results. Steve Fielding - the man ahead of Nalliah on the ticket - was successfully elected.

Danny Nalliah was born in Colombo, Sri Lanka’s capital, in 1964. In his early years he played in a band in Colombo. After “finding God” Nalliah began to preach to congregations in Sri Lanka and Saudi Arabia. He arrived in Australia in 1997 and founded Catch the Fire Ministries soon afterwards. The group is associated with the Pentecostalist Assemblies of God and has grown to be one of the largest Pentecostal churches in the country. Ten thousand people get the Catch the Fire newsletter and Nalliah is now head of Rise Up Australia, a national prayer group with over a hundred affiliated churches.

On Australia Day this year, Nalliah held a service at Melbourne’s Festival Hall, a venue normally reserved for rock concerts. Prime Minister John Howard agreed to provide a DVD message for the service. Margaret Simons described the event in her book “Faith, Money and Power”. The venue was bedecked in Australian flags and Catch the Fire’s flame-coloured banners. A choir sang on a stage backdropped by pictures of Uluru. An usherette danced in the aisle while waving a flag. Simons instinctively recognised a dangerous combination of religious and nationalistic fervour.

Nalliah spoke to the assembled audience. His speech on this occasion was benign but fitted in with the theme. He praised the “freedom of Australia”, thanked the armed forces serving overseas, emergency services fighting bushfires and prayed for the country’s leaders. He was followed on stage by other pastors and then some students, one of whom denounced postmodernism “with its claim that truth is a matter of opinion”.

After an hour and a half Nalliah finally introduced the message from John Howard. Nalliah said that Catch the Fire had also approached Opposition leader Kevin Rudd to send a message but Rudd was unable to do so “because of all his business and travel”. On his DVD speech, Howard spoke of the shared values and of the “great contribution Christianity has made to our country”. He concluded by congratulating Catch the Fire for “bringing Christians from many denominations together for this celebration” and he wished them all a very happy Australia Day. His minute long address was lacklustre and greeted with muted applause and cynical laughter. While Howard was widely criticised for making the DVD, the audience didn’t care about it at all. Simons said many had left the auditorium before the speech ended.

Nalliah has not decided to stand for election this time round. However the pastor has thrown his support behind the Prime Minister and his heir apparent Peter Costello. In a letter sent to the Catch the Fire faithful, he said the Lord had told him to meet personally with Howard and Costello. There Nalliah was to “prophetically prepare Federal Treasurer Peter Costello as the future Prime Minister of Australia”. Nalliah met Costello on 9 August and Howard one day later. Unfortunately he could not share the timing of the Costello handover with his flock or disclose what else transpired in the meetings. But whatever he said, it had resonance. Howard continues to stand by Danny Nalliah despite his racist rants.

Friday, November 02, 2007

Suntech predicts cheaper solar power

Chinese solar company Suntech Power said today it expects solar cell prices to go down as early as 2008 fuelling demand for solar energy. Suntech Power makes silicon photovoltaic cells for solar panels. Up to now the industry has been heavily subsided by government grants which have kept customer prices high. Suntech boss Sri Zhengrong said “price cuts would allow the industry to flourish without artificial supports, increasing its transparency”.

The biggest impediment to keeping prices low is likely to be the availability of silicon. There is a severe worldwide shortage of poly-crystalline silicon which could last for five years. Polysilicon prices have doubled in less than two years and are expected to rise by another 30 per cent in each of the next three years. The problem is due to the fact that polysilicon is also used to make silicon chips and there is competing demand between the booming semi-conductor industry and the rapidly expanding solar sector.

Suntech is the world’s fourth largest solar cell maker. Suntech Power is listed on Nasdaq capitalised at $US5.5 billion. 44 year old owner Shi Zhengrong, an Australian citizen, is now the richest man in China. Forbes estimate his personal wealth in 2006 at $2.2 billion. Remarkably China accounted for just 10 percent of sales. Most of Suntech's equipment is exported to Europe. Its key markets are Germany, Japan and Spain, all of which have statutory requirements for utilities to buy solar-generated power. The company sales soared 165 percent from 2005 to 2006, getting to just short of $600 million for the year.

Now it is beginning to focus on America. Currently the US accounts for just 3 per cent of Suntech’s sales. On Tuesday the company announced San Francisco would be its US headquarters. Zhengrong said that the US was slow to take up solar but that within two or three years it could become the world's largest solar market. He believes this growth will be spurred by abundant sunshine and leadership from states such as California. Looking beyond solar cells, he wants the company to design whole solar systems. Zhengrong said Suntech may establish a research centre in Arizona or California, and may want to buy more small solar companies.

Shi Zhengrong established his solar power panel manufacturing enterprise in 2001. Zhengrong was educated in Shanghai where he obtained a master's degree in laser physics. He moved to Sydney to study optics in the late 1980s. In 1989 he became a PhD student in the groundbreaking photovoltaics laboratory run by two University of NSW professors and solar pioneers Martin Green and Stuart Wenham. In 1995 Zhengrong was appointed deputy director for research at Pacific Solar, a co-operative venture between the university and Pacific Power. Zhengrong took out Australian citizenship and seemed content to stay in Sydney.

But he changed his mind after a 2000 visit to his homeland. Zhengrong was excited by the rapid development he saw and was persuaded to return to Wuxi on the outskirts of Shanghai to start up Suntech Power selling solar equipment. The company started with 20 employees and $11m in government grants. The company quickly turned a profit and by 2005 Suntech (STP) successfully launched on the New York Stock Exchange. It is now the largest solar module manufacturer in the world, has four production sites in China and employs 4,000 staff globally.

Despite Zhengrong being the product of the local university system, Australia has been slow to take up the challenge of solar power. Lack of funding and government climate change scepticism has irreparably damaged the industry here. Murdoch University Professor of Energy Studies Dr Phillip Jennings said scientists would lose research grants if they openly criticised Federal Government policies on renewable energy or climate change. “I think the Government has had a stopgap, sort of stop and go, approach to renewable energy,” he said. “Every time criticism has arisen or a crisis has blown up, they've thrown some more money at it.”

The government has short-sightedly stripped solar energy of research funding, as well as closing the Energy Research and Development Corporation and the Cooperative Research Centre for Renewable Energy. Former federal energy policy adviser Guy Pearce has blamed vested interests. “It's important to understand that some of the same interests who have persuaded our government to avoid emission cuts domestically also have an interest in domestic nuclear power,” he said. “Our two biggest uranium producers are also in the coal and aluminium business”.